September 24, 201610 yr We agree. So let's stop talking about "if he would have....." It's irrelevant. He either made a move to give her a legit reason or he didn't. I thought you were posing possible scenarios in post #506. I'll rephrase the question. Is there any testimony that may come forward that would exonerate officer Shelby? If your answer is yes then we agree.
September 24, 201610 yr I thought you were posing possible scenarios in post #506. I'll rephrase the question. Is there any testimony that may come forward that would exonerate officer Shelby? If your answer is yes then we agree. If in a court of law she's found not guilty, I'm good with that. I trust in our justice system (in most cases) and will almost always accept their rulings.
September 24, 201610 yr If in a court of law she's found not guilty, I'm good with that. I trust in our justice system (in most cases) and will almost always accept their rulings. I tend to be the same way. If the evidence validates her guilt, I'll be the first to support her punishment.
September 24, 201610 yr I thought you were posing possible scenarios in post #506. I'll rephrase the question. Is there any testimony that may come forward that would exonerate officer Shelby? If your answer is yes then we agree. And what about the real life scenario that the officer next to her used a taser to subdue the subject and she used her gun?
September 24, 201610 yr Regarding the "he didn't obey commands/he's not the good guy everyone says" comments: Let's say the guy did/said the following to the officer. 1. Said "screw" you or some form of that sentiment when she told him to do something 2. Called her the ultimate 4-letter female pejorative 3. Told him what she could do to him sexually 4. Spit on her 5. Told her he was going to kill her after he got out of jail but 6. kept his hands on the closed window Do 1 through 5 give her enough justification to shoot him? Just my opinion- None of the above should result in a shooting but walking toward the car does escalate the situation to the point where the officer needs to be ready to shoot to defend herself. Every step he takes toward the car puts his life in greater danger. Whether the window is up or down, proximity to the unknown of what may be in that car coupled with a refusal to comply justifies strong consideration for use of deadly force.
September 24, 201610 yr And what about the real life scenario that the officer next to her used a taser to subdue the subject and she used her gun? The autopsy could be interesting. Taser combined with PCP (if in fact he was on it) could be a part of the issue in conjunction of the gun? Could other cop get charged as well? Get shot and you bleed, get hit with a taser and it makes your heart pump faster I'm guessing? All hypothetical, but who knows???
September 24, 201610 yr The autopsy could be interesting. Taser combined with PCP (if in fact he was on it) could be a part of the issue in conjunction of the gun? Could other cop get charged as well? Get shot and you bleed, get hit with a taser and it makes your heart pump faster I'm guessing? All hypothetical, but who knows??? Who needs a hypothetical? One cop used a taser. The other used a gun.
September 24, 201610 yr Who needs a hypothetical? One cop used a taser. The other used a gun. So could the other cop get charged as well?
September 24, 201610 yr And what about the real life scenario that the officer next to her used a taser to subdue the subject and she used her gun? I am really not sure about procedure in these incidents. Rocket28 commented that typically you wouldn't want everyone to have a taser. I believe that one officer was was not brandishing his firearm or taser. The fact that both officers fire nearly at the same time tells me that they saw something concerning enough to react. Testimony from the other officers could ultimately decide Shelbys fate. PP92, could their be any testimony that would exonerate Shelby in your opinion?
September 24, 201610 yr I am really not sure about procedure in these incidents. Rocket28 commented that typically you wouldn't want everyone to have a taser. I believe that one officer was was not brandishing his firearm or taser. The fact that both officers fire nearly at the same time tells me that they saw something concerning enough to react. Testimony from the other officers could ultimately decide Shelbys fate. PP92, could their be any testimony that would exonerate Shelby in your opinion? Of course. I honestly don't expect to ever see her sent to prison for this. I don't know enough to say if she should or shouldn't be sent to prison. I can only say how things look to me and that doesn't count for anything.
September 24, 201610 yr So could the other cop get charged as well? Not likely, I'd say his departments policy would likely authorize use of the taser under those circumstances. However that all depends on exactly what happened up to that moment.
September 25, 201610 yr Regarding the "he didn't obey commands/he's not the good guy everyone says" comments: Let's say the guy did/said the following to the officer. 1. Said "screw" you or some form of that sentiment when she told him to do something 2. Called her the ultimate 4-letter female pejorative 3. Told him what she could do to him sexually 4. Spit on her 5. Told her he was going to kill her after he got out of jail but 6. kept his hands on the closed window Do 1 through 5 give her enough justification to shoot him? #5 sure does.
September 25, 201610 yr Author #5 sure does. Zero chance she stays out of jail if that's why she fired.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.