I was thinking about this. Which pro sport has stars with the most longevity while competing at the top level of the game?

 

I think for the sake of discussion, we should throw out golf, auto racing, and sports related to fishing/hunting.

I'd think the NFL. You can be a Kicker into your deep 40's.

Baseball pitchers can be really good for a long time.

But which sport would you say that the average athlete is allowed the longest window for top-notch success?

I think Olympic sports are likely to be the winner in the discussion, personally.

Something that does not high level of physical abuse. Olympic sports (track/swimming/marathon/biathalon/etc.) pitchers in baseball, golfers.

I don't know that the average peak years for any sport are terribly long. The key word here is average. While stars can have extended runs at the top of their game, most of the pro's aren't stars. That being said, Football is probably the toughest because of the physical abuse. Baseball is tough because of the length of the season, but many stars can be top players for over a decade. The NBA is pretty close to baseball with a long, grinding season, but many of the top guys have extended runs at the top. Otherwise, I think all of the individual sports generally aren't contact based, and offer a better opportunity for long periods of high level success.

But which sport would you say that the average athlete is allowed the longest window for top-notch success?

 

Golf, no question.

The fact that Vince Carter is still going at 40+ leads me to believe the NBA is the answer as far as "stars" go, but then there's D-Rose so...

 

Baseball is the answer. Steroids are to thank, though exceptions can be made.

Baseball

Athletes Who Were Great the Longest | Bleacher Report

I realize you say 'average' athlete but when I looked at this article baseball players were mentioned more than other sports.

I'll say baseball, for a reason nobody has mentioned...the minor leagues. In basketball and football, there's ton of new talent coming out of college each and every year. And the majority of those draft choices have to go somewhere, and usually it's the roster...meaning somebody that was there last year, is now gone. With baseball, even a top prospect may spend anywhere from 2-4 years in the minors. Only if they survive there do they get brought up. And only then do they push out a veteran.

 

I think that allows an "average" player the chance to stay in the sport much, much longer than any of the other leagues.

If you are talking all sports (olympic) I would think equestrian sports would be near the top.

If you are talking all sports (olympic) I would think equestrian sports would be near the top.

 

Not real athletes in the same way as the major sports. Thoroughbred jockeys are a different story, though.

I go with baseball, but thoroughbred jockeys are right up there. As long as they stay healthy and off the booze and drugs, there's a 30-year career for them if they have a nose for the finish line.

Not real athletes in the same way as the major sports. Thoroughbred jockeys are a different story, though.

 

It depends on the discipline for the Olympics. Eventers are better athletes than jockeys as they are doing the exact same thing as jockeys except for 10-12 minutes while jumping immovable fences during the cross country phase. They're just not battling 10 other horses next to them. The show jumpers are athletic but they don't have to go as long (about as long as jockey). Dressage riders, well, they don't need to be athletic.