September 7, 20188 yr I would play Senzel in Right Field, Schebler in CF, and Winker in Left if I had too. It is amazing that we worry about position they play yet the Big Red Machine guys played everywhere. I believe that Old Pete made the All star game at 7 different positions, I can not remember I just know it freaked me out to see that stat. I like the idea of moving Scooter as well if it can help land us a starting pitcher and agree we have to spend some money, and according to management we are going too. Mustang who would you like to see as manager next year>. Wish list?
September 7, 20188 yr I would play Senzel in Right Field, Schebler in CF, and Winker in Left if I had too. It is amazing that we worry about position they play yet the Big Red Machine guys played everywhere. I believe that Old Pete made the All star game at 7 different positions, I can not remember I just know it freaked me out to see that stat. I like the idea of moving Scooter as well if it can help land us a starting pitcher and agree we have to spend some money, and according to management we are going too. Mustang who would you like to see as manager next year>. Wish list? Senzel has had multiple bouts of vertigo. I just wouldn't risk it with moving him to a position that involves getting turned around, potential wall crashes, etc. I'd probably have Girardi at the top of my list, but I'll be content with anyone that puts an emphasis on analytics. Honestly, as long as it isn't Riggleman, I'll probably be happy.
September 7, 20188 yr Mark Sheldon Verified account @m_sheldon 6m6 minutes ago At a season ticket holder luncheon, Riggleman announced that Tyler Mahle will replace Homer Bailey in the rotation #Reds 1 reply 12 retweets 33 likes Only about 5 months too late....
September 7, 20188 yr Don't be surprised if Homer is in the rotation at opening day next year. The sad fact is the young pitchers have not forced the Reds' hand to take Bailey out of the rotation. With the financial commitment the Reds have to Bailey, he is getting to get the nod if there is any room for debate.
September 7, 20188 yr Don't be surprised if Homer is in the rotation at opening day next year. The sad fact is the young pitchers have not forced the Reds' hand to take Bailey out of the rotation. With the financial commitment the Reds have to Bailey, he is getting to get the nod if there is any room for debate. That's the thing. There's no room for debate. They're all better than him at this point.
September 7, 20188 yr That's the thing. There's no room for debate. They're all better than him at this point. Is it that clear cut? I understand letting the youngsters pitch and get experience. It is definitely a good move benching Bailey the rest of the way and letting the youngsters get more innings and experience. But when next year rolls around and the Reds are going to try to compete, the young pitchers need to make it clear they are better and will give the team a better chance at winning. Personally, I haven't seen that clear cut advantage out of any of the young pitchers yet except Castillo. If it was opening day tomorrow and I had to set the Reds rotation from the current roster, I would have: 1. Desclafani 2. Castillo 3. Harvey 4. toss up 5. toss up Since it is very doubtful Harvey is here next year, that makes 3 of the starting slots a toss up. Do the Reds have 3 better starters on their roster right now than Bailey?
September 7, 20188 yr IMO, yes. Romano, Mahle, Reed, Stephenson, Sims, etc. If you look at the numbers, there's no argument for Bailey over anyone.
September 7, 20188 yr Author IMO, yes. Romano, Mahle, Reed, Stephenson, Sims, etc. If you look at the numbers, there's no argument for Bailey over anyone. Well Stephenson does have an ERA of over 9 so you could argue Bailey over him and Romano's numbers as a starter are only marginally better. But DeSclafani, Castillo, Mahle and Reed for sure.
September 7, 20188 yr Well Stephenson does have an ERA of over 9 so you could argue Bailey over him and Romano's numbers as a starter are only marginally better. But DeSclafani, Castillo, Mahle and Reed for sure. I'd argue Stephenson's only thrown 3 games, so the ERA # is skewed. Romano's numbers aren't a ton better, but he has been better and should only continue to improve. And I'm not saying Stephenson should be in the rotation at all. Simply that he's a better option, IMO, than Bailey.
September 7, 20188 yr They simply have to add SP this off season if they are serious about doing anything.
September 7, 20188 yr Author They simply have to add SP this off season if they are serious about doing anything. Unless they add at least 2 #1 or #2 level starters I think they're still the 4th best team in the division.
September 7, 20188 yr Unless they add at least 2 #1 or #2 level starters I think they're still the 4th best team in the division. Probably, but they should have some cash to spend and they have assets to trade.
September 7, 20188 yr IMO, yes. Romano, Mahle, Reed, Stephenson, Sims, etc. If you look at the numbers, there's no argument for Bailey over anyone. Stephenson? I'm okay giving him a shot this September but if he is anything like what he has shown this year I say it is time to move on. I am all for giving those guys Innings the rest of the season and giving them opportunity in spring training. The question is when do we say what we have seen is all we can expect?
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.