February 6, 20179 yr Donovan McNabb deserves to be in the HOF before Michael Vick. I agree, and Donovan McNabb doesn't deserve to be in the Hall of Fame.
February 6, 20179 yr I agree, and Donovan McNabb doesn't deserve to be in the Hall of Fame. Unfortunately I agree with you. Always been a huge McNabb fan, but I think the falls short of the Hall. So if he's short, Vick definitely is, in my opinion.
February 6, 20179 yr I will say that Ron Mexico was about as electrifying and as box office of an attraction for the years he was rolling in Atlanta. His numbers were not great, but his dual threatness made him one of the more effective QBs in the league. It was not a coincidence that Atlanta had the top rushing attack in the league during Vick's tenure.
February 6, 20179 yr Per Profootballreference.com, which compares careers of players, Michael Vick compares statistically to: Joe Theismann Joe Namath Tony Romo Trent Green Matt Ryan Steve McNair Carson Palmer Steve Grogan Jim Everett Kurt Warner Using this, he's closer than most probably think, but I'd still say no. Michael Vick Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com
February 6, 20179 yr Per Profootballreference.com, which compares careers of players, Michael Vick compares statistically to: Joe Theismann Joe Namath Tony Romo Trent Green Matt Ryan Steve McNair Carson Palmer Steve Grogan Jim Everett Kurt Warner Using this, he's closer than most probably think, but I'd still say no. Michael Vick Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com I had looked at that too and I don't know how Football Reference can say he compares to Kurt Warner for instance...numbers wise it's not really that close. Vick 56% passer with just over 20K yards 80.4QBR Warner 65% passer with over 32K yards (in 20 less games) 93.7QBR Vick has better numbers than Namath and some others, but lacks compared to most on that list.
February 6, 20179 yr Author Per Profootballreference.com, which compares careers of players, Michael Vick compares statistically to: Joe Theismann Joe Namath Tony Romo Trent Green Matt Ryan Steve McNair Carson Palmer Steve Grogan Jim Everett Kurt Warner Using this, he's closer than most probably think, but I'd still say no. Michael Vick Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com There is no way he compares close to many on that list. As Jumper_Dad pointed out he isn't even in the same zip code to Kurt Warner on that list. I'd give him Theismann and Namath because the only reason they got in the HOF is because of popularity. He won a SB but was not a great QB compared to others in the same era who didn't make it in, ie Ken Anderson. But at the same time, Vick played in the era where the game was all meant for a QB's success with all the rule changes etc. Vick would have probably been closer to 40% compl% if he played in the 70's and 80's. Instead Vick was afforded to play in the most QB friendly era ever for QB's where a QB better complete 60% of his passes on a regular basis or he would be among the bottom half of the league. Moving on to some others on the list Tony Romo's stats make Vicks look horrible. Romo who will never see the HOF or get close has a compl% of 65% and QB Rating of 97 Trent Green who won't sniff the HOF either has much better stats than Vick also. 60% and 86 Rating Matt Ryan stats blow Vicks out of the water with a 65% compl % and a 93 QB Rating Steve McNair 60% and 83 QB Rating Carson Palmer 62% and 88 QB Rating Steve Grogan.....lol, Steve Grogan!!! LOL If you want to compare yourself to Steve Grogan then HOF should never be in your vocabulary. Steve Grogan probably isn't even allowed in the state of Ohio where the HOF is at because he was that bad. OK, Mike Vick is just like Steve Grogan..lol He can have that one. Oh and you can have Jim Everett too lol We were talking HOF I thought. Kurt Warner, well Vick can't even carry his jock strap. Profootballreference.com needs a little help when they compare players because this list you provided is a joke.
February 6, 20179 yr There is no way he compares close to many on that list. As Jumper_Dad pointed out he isn't even in the same zip code to Kurt Warner on that list. I'd give him Theismann and Namath because the only reason they got in the HOF is because of popularity. He won a SB but was not a great QB compared to others in the same era who didn't make it in, ie Ken Anderson. But at the same time, Vick played in the era where the game was all meant for a QB's success with all the rule changes etc. Vick would have probably been closer to 40% compl% if he played in the 70's and 80's. Instead Vick was afforded to play in the most QB friendly era ever for QB's where a QB better complete 60% of his passes on a regular basis or he would be among the bottom half of the league. Moving on to some others on the list Tony Romo's stats make Vicks look horrible. Romo who will never see the HOF or get close has a compl% of 65% and QB Rating of 97 Trent Green who won't sniff the HOF either has much better stats than Vick also. 60% and 86 Rating Matt Ryan stats blow Vicks out of the water with a 65% compl % and a 93 QB Rating Steve McNair 60% and 83 QB Rating Carson Palmer 62% and 88 QB Rating Steve Grogan.....lol, Steve Grogan!!! LOL If you want to compare yourself to Steve Grogan then HOF should never be in your vocabulary. Steve Grogan probably isn't even allowed in the state of Ohio where the HOF is at because he was that bad. OK, Mike Vick is just like Steve Grogan..lol He can have that one. Oh and you can have Jim Everett too lol We were talking HOF I thought. Kurt Warner, well Vick can't even carry his jock strap. Profootballreference.com needs a little help when they compare players because this list you provided is a joke. Dang dude, don't shoot the messenger.
February 6, 20179 yr Author Dang dude, don't shoot the messenger.Lol, it wasn't directed at you but to Profootballreference.com which made a pretty silly comparison.
February 6, 20179 yr Not that I have a dog in the fight, but didn't he miss some games while he was still in his prime for some reason?
February 6, 20179 yr Not that I have a dog in the fight, but didn't he miss some games while he was still in his prime for some reason? I see what you did there. Still too soon for me. I'll never forgive him because of this.
February 6, 20179 yr Not that I have a dog in the fight, but didn't he miss some games while he was still in his prime for some reason? Wow. That's ruff. :lol2:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.