NFL Rookie of the Year 2012

[PurplePride92]

Who should win this? Three horse race and I am undecided going into week 17.

 

Really can't go wrong with any of them.

[PurplePride92]

Stats at Week 16.....

 

Russell Wilson:

 

98.0 QB Rating

63.4% completion percentage

2868 yards passing

25 passing touchdowns

431 rushing yards

3 rushing touchdowns

 

Seattle is 10-5 and in the playoffs.

[PurplePride92]

Andrew Luck:

 

75.6 QB Rating

4183 passing yards(Rookie record)

54.3% completion percentage

21 passing touchdowns

254 yards rushing

5 rushing touchdowns

 

Team is 10-5 and in the playoffs.

[PurplePride92]

Robert Griffin III:

 

104.1 QB Rating

66.4% completion percentage

3100 yards passing

20 passing touchdowns

752 rushing yards(Rookie record)

6 rushing touchdowns

 

Team is 9-6 and currently in first in the NFC East.

[Big Slick]

All 3 are great, but I think Luck wins it.

[NEERFAN]

I have to go with Luck. Top to bottom the Colts were the worst team of the three involved. +8 games in the win column tells me he's pretty valuable. Great rookie crop in 2013.

[Blue Magic]

Now I'm going to give my unbiased opinion, blocking out the fact that I have a future bet on Luck winning ROY. I think RG3 and Wilson suck and Luck should definitely win it.

[Clyde]

Tough call but I side with Luck.

[SvFan4life]

Luck IMO.

[jolmstead]

Of these three, which one is least likely to be exposed in the playoffs?

 

Wilson. If Wilson played for an east coast team, he would be the winner hands down. Wilson beat Brady. Neither of other two candidates could carry Brady's jock! Argument over!

[PurplePride92]

Of these three, which one is least likely to be exposed in the playoffs?

 

Wilson. If Wilson played for an east coast team, he would be the winner hands down. Wilson beat Brady. Neither of other two candidates could carry Brady's jock! Argument over!

 

Wilson beat Brady and Rodgers.

[PurplePride92]

I'm leaning Wilson but if the Redskins win the NFC East I say give it to RGIII. He'd be the only one of the 3 to win their division.

 

 

What blows my mind is how even their team success and stats are. I hope all 3 only continue to get better. The NFL will be in great hands with those 3 being successful.

[katbird]

RG3........

[born2reign]

It will go to one of the QB's, but let me say this: Alfred Morris has over 1400 yards rushing (fourth in the league going into week 17) and 10 TD's. He never gets mentioned in this conversation because he is on the same team as RG3, but he should get more love than he does, IMO.

 

After last night, I am personally leaning toward Wilson. I think Luck will win the award, however.

[PurplePride92]

Very true about Alfred Morris.