Of these three, which one is least likely to be exposed in the playoffs?

 

Wilson. If Wilson played for an east coast team, he would be the winner hands down. Wilson beat Brady. Neither of other two candidates could carry Brady's jock! Argument over!

 

Anyone else feel like this is one of those statements we will look back on in 5 years and laugh at the notion?

Anyone else feel like this is one of those statements we will look back on in 5 years and laugh at the notion?

 

I do but at the same time this argument is set up to call Luck and RGIII failures if they don't win 3 Super Bowls. I wish we could celebrate young QBs achievements without setting them up to unrealistic expectations. Let's be real...how many QBs in the history of the game can hold Brady's jock? That's a different question than who can hold Brady's jock in 2012. I'd take a bunch of different QBs in 2012 before Brady. Career wise though, Brady is in the top tier.

I do but at the same time this argument is set up to call Luck and RGIII failures if they don't win 3 Super Bowls. I wish we could celebrate young QBs achievements without setting them up to unrealistic expectations. Let's be real...how many QBs in the history of the game can hold Brady's jock? That's a different question than who can hold Brady's jock in 2012. I'd take a bunch of different QBs in 2012 before Brady. Career wise though, Brady is in the top tier.

 

Besides Rodgers, who the heck else could you take before Brady? Manning? Maybe. Brees? Nah. I don't think anyone else is even close.

Besides Rodgers, who the heck else could you take before Brady? Manning? Maybe. Brees? Nah. I don't think anyone else is even close.

 

In 2012? I'd take Rodgers, Ryan, Brees, P. Manning, Griffin and Wilson off the top of my head. I can be talked into others. Brady in 2012 isn't the same Brady and he hasn't won a Super Bowl since when? 2004? 2005?

In 2012? I'd take Rodgers, Ryan, Brees, P. Manning, Griffin and Wilson off the top of my head. I can be talked into others. Brady in 2012 isn't the same Brady and he hasn't won a Super Bowl since when? 2004? 2005?

 

Me, you, and your clone start a three team league. You take Ryan and Russell Wilson with your two teams and I'll laugh my way to a Superbowl. Brady, even not in his prime, still has better numbers than both of them.

Me, you, and your clone start a three team league. You take Ryan and Russell Wilson with your two teams and I'll laugh my way to a Superbowl. Brady, even not in his prime, still has better numbers than both of them.

 

And yet he still finds a way to lose to John Skelton, Colin Kaepernick and Russell Wilson in 2012. It ain't 2007 anymore.