If you had to trade one for pitching....

Who would you trade first -- Senzel, Trammell or Greene

Greene is untouchable.

Senzel.

Who would you trade first -- Senzel, Trammell or Greene

Depends on who we get in return. I wouldn’t trade any of these guys this year, zero chance of winning.

Depends on who we get in return. I wouldn’t trade any of these guys this year, zero chance of winning.

Assume in return its a top of the rotation pitcher.

Assume in return its a top of the rotation pitcher.

Gotta see his contract too.

Gotta see his contract too.

Why does the contract matter? All I'm asking is which one of the top 3 prospects would you be willing to part with first. This stems from a conversation I had with a co-worker this morning.

Senzel Infield is a position of strength.

Here is the biggest key to all this. Are we trading for a true #1 Starter, or someone that would be a #1 Starter on the Reds. Big difference between the two.

Senzel. Organizationally the Reds need Trammell and Greene more.

Senzel Infield is a position of strength.

Agreed...

I agree with Senzel. My co-worker said Greene because he's so far away and is probably 3-4 years away from contributing.

He's most likely the furthest away but he also has the highest ceiling. Also, this organization needs to develop or trade for top pitching. Most free agents are not going to consider playing half their games GABP unless the Reds overpay

I agree with Senzel. My co-worker said Greene because he's so far away and is probably 3-4 years away from contributing.

 

He's most likely the furthest away but he also has the highest ceiling. Also, this organization needs to develop or trade for top pitching. Most free agents are not going to consider playing half their games GABP unless the Reds overpay

Most top shelf pictures also have trade clauses in their contracts.

Senzel for Degrom?

Senzel for Degrom?

In a heartbeat but I doubt the Mets would go for 1 to 1, it would take more than Senzel. DeGrom is under control for 3 more years.