Tony Romo

I would go with Rivers, but he has looked really good in his first two games.

Brady is a 3x Super Bowl champ. And he's been to 5 total Super Bowls. Who in the heck would say he's over rated?

 

A lot of people. Not saying he isn't a great qb, but he is a direct result of a good system. The support for that argument would be Matt Cassell in the 2008 season. That first Super Bowl team was absolutely a defensive team not a Brady team also.

Edited September 17, 201313 yr by JokersWild24

A lot of people. Not saying he isn't a great qb, but he is a direct result of a good system. The support for that argument would be Matt Cassell in the 2008 season. That first Super Bowl team was absolutely a defensive team not a Brady team also.

 

2008 was the only year in the last 10 seasons, that the Patriots did not make the playoffs. I'm no Brady fan, but the system runs much better with him at the helm.

After watching the first half of MNF, maybe Dalton should be put on the list. He sux.

Have you ever had Dalton rated all that highly to begin with? You are not judging if he is good or bad.

Matt Schaub is up there for me.

 

Don't you have to be considered a Top 10 guy to be over-rated?

 

I think the perception exists that the best 10 guys are:

 

Manning

Manning

Brady

Rodgers

Brees

Kaepernick

Ryan

Flacco

Luck

Stafford

 

Next group would be, in my opinion, Wilson, Newton, Schaub, Romo and Rivers. Not in that order. Hard for Dalton to be over-rated when I don't think anyone has him as a Top 15 guy. To me, of the guys in that perceived Top 10, I think Flacco is the most over-rated, followed closely by Stafford.

2008 was the only year in the last 10 seasons, that the Patriots did not make the playoffs. I'm no Brady fan, but the system runs much better with him at the helm.

 

They still went 11-5. Sometimes some teams are just better.

Have you ever had Dalton rated all that highly to begin with? You are not judging if he is good or bad.

 

Actually I had him rated high his rookie season. Thought the things he needed to improve on would be sime fixes if he worked hard. His second season I saw him taking steps backwards.

I voted Romo.

Don't you have to be considered a Top 10 guy to be over-rated?

 

I think the perception exists that the best 10 guys are:

 

Manning

Manning

Brady

Rodgers

Brees

Kaepernick

Ryan

Flacco

Luck

Stafford

 

Next group would be, in my opinion, Wilson, Newton, Schaub, Romo and Rivers. Not in that order. Hard for Dalton to be over-rated when I don't think anyone has him as a Top 15 guy. To me, of the guys in that perceived Top 10, I think Flacco is the most over-rated, followed closely by Stafford.

 

Who considers Stafford a Top 10 QB? Roethlisberger easily makes that list over Stafford, and I'm not even that crazy about him.

Actually I had him rated high his rookie season. Thought the things he needed to improve on would be sime fixes if he worked hard. His second season I saw him taking steps backwards.

 

I hear people say that a lot, but in almost every category but interceptions Dalton did better in his 2nd year than his rookie year. I think his rookie year most people on here were so glad to have Palmer gone, that they liked anything Dalton did. Then in his 2nd year they expected much bigger things from him, and he did improve in a lot of areas last year. However it wasn't the huge improvement people wanted. This 3rd year is the year that he should show that big improvement. He did for one game, last night not so much.

After watching the first half of MNF, maybe Dalton should be put on the list. He sux.

 

Still votes for Dalton....take the tiger stripped googles off folks. He's AWFUL.

Who considers Stafford a Top 10 QB? Roethlisberger easily makes that list over Stafford, and I'm not even that crazy about him.

I was just flying off the top of my head, and I feel like Stafford gets a lot of love. I feel like Big Ben's popularity as jumped the shark, so to speak. Maybe I'm nuts.

Eli Manning once again today showed why he is one of the most overrated QB's.

0 pts and yet another int. He now has 8 Int's in just the first 3 games.

Colin Kaepernick stock dropping quickly...is it too late to sell?