E. Manning has no chance with that offensive line. No one can survive that.

Eli Manning once again today showed why he is one of the most overrated QB's. 0 pts and yet another int. He now has 8 Int's in just the first 3 games.

 

You obviously are looking only at stats. If you watched the game you'd know what you are saying is wrong.

 

Eli might lose his streak of consecutive starts if the offensive line doesn't improve. He was sacked 7-8 times and hit many more. He was getting pressured many times before he was even back and ready to throw.

You obviously are looking only at stats. If you watched the game you'd know what you are saying is wrong.

 

Eli might lose his streak of consecutive starts if the offensive line doesn't improve. He was sacked 7-8 times and hit many more. He was getting pressured many times before he was even back and ready to throw.

Eli Manning has the most turnovers since 2010. Sorry, he is a turnover machine.

Vick...the new Eagles offense has helped resurrect his career, but he is nothing like the player he was early on.

You obviously are looking only at stats. If you watched the game you'd know what you are saying is wrong.

 

Eli might lose his streak of consecutive starts if the offensive line doesn't improve. He was sacked 7-8 times and hit many more. He was getting pressured many times before he was even back and ready to throw.

 

Why when Romo was in the same situation last year, these excuses weren't made for him? Not only last year he hasn't had a good line since 09.

Why when Romo was in the same situation last year, these excuses weren't made for him? Not only last year he hasn't had a good line since 09.

 

He hasn't had a good line since ever, it's just now starting to get better.

Why when Romo was in the same situation last year, these excuses weren't made for him? Not only last year he hasn't had a good line since 09.

 

Very true and Romo's rating has always been 90 or higher. I can't bash Romo too much, he gets it done with the crap he's given.

Why when Romo was in the same situation last year, these excuses weren't made for him?

 

He doesn't have two Super Bowl wins.

 

His last name isn't Manning.

Eli Manning has the most turnovers since 2010. Sorry, he is a turnover machine.

 

I said absolutely nothing about that. You did read my post before you answered, right?

 

I'm calling your comment that he's the most overrated QB in the league downright insane. And what made your comment even more insane, is that you based this opinion partly on his performance against Carolina. If you had watched the game (it's obvious you didn't watch 10 seconds of the Giants offense) you'd know that Eli was on his back many times before he finished dropping back. Eli Manning is not even remotely close to being the reason they lost to Carolina. It all falls on the offensive line.

Very true and Romo's rating has always been 90 or higher. I can't bash Romo too much, he gets it done with the crap he's given.

 

How many playoff games he won?

 

Statistically, Romo is better than Eli. With that said, I'd take Eli every day over Romo. When you need a touchdown or game winning drive, Eli can get it done and get it done in the biggest games. Romo...not so much.

Why when Romo was in the same situation last year, these excuses weren't made for him? Not only last year he hasn't had a good line since 09.

 

People make excuses for Romo all the time. I think Romo is a good QB. I think he used to be a tad bit over rated, but now everyone knows what they're gonna get from Romo. They will get good stats and a few wins, but he's not gonna lead a team to a championship.

People make excuses for Romo all the time. I think Romo is a good QB. I think he used to be a tad bit over rated, but now everyone knows what they're gonna get from Romo. They will get good stats and a few wins, but he's not gonna lead a team to a championship.

 

Pretty spot on IMO.

 

I do think he finally breaks through and wins a playoff game this year though. They're going to win the division (by default), so he'll get a home playoff game.

Pretty spot on IMO.

 

I do think he finally breaks through and wins a playoff game this year though. They're going to win the division (by default), so he'll get a home playoff game.

 

I'm not necessarily ready to give them the division. I mean honestly would you be surprised if Dallas loses 4 in a row? Philly could win 4 in a row. The Giants could win 4 in a row. Washington could win 4 in a row. It's a brutally terrible division right now which makes me to believe a 2 game lead is nothing.

I'm not necessarily ready to give them the division. I mean honestly would you be surprised if Dallas loses 4 in a row? Philly could win 4 in a row. The Giants could win 4 in a row. Washington could win 4 in a row. It's a brutally terrible division right now which makes me to believe a 2 game lead is nothing.

 

Wouldn't surprise me, but because it's so bad, I'm sticking with the team with the best skill players and that's Dallas.

Wouldn't surprise me, but because it's so bad, I'm sticking with the team with the best skill players and that's Dallas.

 

 

I don't even agree that Dallas has the best skill players.

 

They might have the best offensive line, which would make me give them an advantage.