I think they are fairly evenly matched. I think a team that has beaten another team twice could overlook an opponent or be overly confident. I think a team that has played an opponent twice knows what to expect and could change their strategy and fix their mistakes from the first couple of games.
I think season 1 was kind of slow getting started, but the second half of the season was much better.
I saw in Entertainment Weekly that Charles Logan will be back this season.
Ky Post article with game stats...
http://www.kypost.com/content/sportsandscores/story/12-5-Boys-Basketball-Scott-Muscles-Past-Male/IRSTHH6IpkqCSrtju8iX8w.cspx?rss=1334