January 21, 200818 yr Making it to the Super Bowl sooner doesn't mean a thing, Eli has a looooooong way to go to begin to compare with Peyton.
January 21, 200818 yr Author Making it to the Super Bowl sooner doesn't mean a thing, Eli has a looooooong way to go to begin to compare with Peyton. He may well never compare to Peyton for all I know or care. Just stirring things up. :banana:
January 21, 200818 yr Eli is playing in the SUPER BOWL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:dancingpa:dancingpa:ylsuper:
January 21, 200818 yr Eli is playing in the SUPER BOWL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:dancingpa:dancingpa:ylsuper: Peyton already won one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :dancingpa :dancingpa
January 21, 200818 yr Eli is playing in the SUPER BOWL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:dancingpa:dancingpa:ylsuper:And I'm cheering for him to win! :dancingpa :dancingpa :dancingpa :ylsuper:
January 21, 200818 yr Peyton already won one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :dancingpa :dancingpa:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
January 21, 200818 yr Three teams I listed lost to the Pats? Well guess what, everyone else that played them did as well. Why don't you break down the AFC's record vs the NFC as well, because I'd assume the majority of their wins over the NFC came over the St.Louis Rams, Carolina Panthers, Atlanta Falcons, and San Francisco 49ers. The argument goes both ways. While I will agree that the NFC is not quite as good as the AFC, it is no where near "awful". The debate goes on... Because you didn't name any AFC teams. You picked 7 NFC teams that just happen to have a combined 22-6 record against the AFC. Most of which was the AFC's worse teams.
January 21, 200818 yr Peyton plays in the better league as well. I'm not so sure the AFC is that much better than the NFC from top to bottom JMO. They just have the one dominate team and a couple of pretty good teams. The Chargers made it to the championship game so that can't say much for your conference because they weren't that good.
January 21, 200818 yr Ok, here are a few of Eli's stellar games this year, to be "stellar" the QB rating had to fall below 70.0 Opponent Comp/Attempts Yards TD INT's Rating Fumbles Wash 21/36 232 1 2 63.7 0 Phil 14-26 135 1 1 65.4 0 Miami 8-22 59 0 0 44.9 1 Minn 21-49 273 1 4 33.8 0 Chicago 16-27 195 1 2 63.0 1 Washington 18-53(34%nice) 184 1 0 51.1 1 Buff 7-15 111 0 2 32.2 5
January 21, 200818 yr Before Joe Montana won all of those super bowls how great was he? Montana won in his 4th year 3rd year as a starter, much like Eli could do...
January 21, 200818 yr I think some of you are not reading the first post...the question is AT THIS POINT IN HIS CAREER is Eli better than Peyton was at this point in his career? (at least that's what I assume he meant because to agrue Eli vs. Peyton right now IS ridiculous) Looking at the stats (which aren't that far off) and how Eli HAS won a big game and how Peyton was knocked for NOT winning a big game all the way up until last year, I don't think it's complete out of the question.
January 21, 200818 yr Looking at the stats (which aren't that far off) . Peyton on his first 4 years Completions are 1357-2226, 16,418 yards, 111 td's, 81 ints Eli Completeions are 987-1805, 11,385 yards, 77 td's, 64 ints I'd say that's pretty far off...
January 21, 200818 yr Wow..what a.....dumb question. Eli may have led his team to the SB, but he isn't playing in the AFC. Eli is no where near Peyton and he will NEVER be CLOSE to his brother. Never..
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.