Eli better than Peyton?!?

[spindoc]

The notion that someone would even ask this question is absurd. They are no-where near close to each other in talent!

Or endorsements!

[00Rocket28]

Here, go look at Eli's first 4 season's stats vs Peyton, NOT EVEN CLOSE!!!!

[halfback20]

Not a particular fan of either BUT

 

Early in Peyton's career he was playing for Jim Mora and a defense that was, to be kind, yeilding.

 

I am less a fan of Tom Coughlin but he does know how to coach a defense.

 

Eli has been the beneficiary of having better people around him.

 

Tom Coughlin is an offensive guy. Steve Spagnuolo is the man who has transformed this defense.

 

Peyton had good players around him early in his career. Edge, Harrison etc...

 

Plax and Shockey are the only big names around Eli. Jacobs and Bradshaw were not very well known before this year.

 

At this point, NO Eli is not better than Peyton. But I think Eli can have a very successful career with more than one super bowl win.

[halfback20]

Here, go look at Eli's first 4 season's stats vs Peyton, NOT EVEN CLOSE!!!!

 

It took Peyton what...9 years to get to a super bowl? Eli did it in his 3rd year as a starter.

[halfback20]

Could you even have this converstation 6 weeks ago? Eli has played very well in his 3 playoff wins but lets get back to earth. Before the playoffs he was an average QB at best.

 

Before Joe Montana won all of those super bowls how great was he?

[halfback20]

Eli has done a good job "managing" the Giants this post season. But, he is not even close to being the QB that Peyton is.

 

Eli did a lot more than "managing" the game last night. That suggestion makes me sick. He threw many GREAT passes last night in FREEZING temperatures. Below ZERO temperatures. Give him some credit where credit is due.

[00Rocket28]

It took Peyton what...9 years to get to a super bowl? Eli did it in his 3rd year as a starter.

 

Once again, apples and oranges, STATS!!!!!!

[racer4life]

Peyton plays for the better team and couldn't get it done.

[stickymitts]

BGP may currently be worse than ESPN...

[00Rocket28]

Anyone who thinks Eli is better than Peyton should stop drinking bong water...

[woodsrider]

It took Peyton what...9 years to get to a super bowl? Eli did it in his 3rd year as a starter.

I didn't realize there was only one player on a football team. The NFC is pretty much awlful and has been for several years. Eli has had a very nice 3 game run but that is all he has to his credit.

[woodsrider]

Peyton plays for the better team and couldn't get it done.

Peyton plays in the better league as well.

[halfback20]

Once again, apples and oranges, STATS!!!!!!

 

It's not apples and oranges. They play the SAME SPORT and the SAME POSITION. :lol:

[PepRock01]

:bunny::bunny::bunny:

 

Dance puppets, dance!

 

:lol:

[halfback20]

I didn't realize there was only one player on a football team. The NFC is pretty much awlful and has been for several years. Eli has had a very nice 3 game run but that is all he has to his credit.

 

The NFC is awful? The Packers and Cowboys were 13-3.

 

The Giants, Cowboys, Eagles, Packers, Lions, Bears, and Cardinals were a combined 22-6 vs the AFC.

 

The NFC overall was 32-33 vs the AFC. Most losses coming from the Rams, Panthers, Saints, Falcons, and 49ers.

 

The NFC is NOT awful this year.