Greg Maddux

Bob Gibson

I would give that Johan guy a few innings to see what he can do.

Bob Gibson

Babe Ruth

John Smoltz

Josh Beckett?

 

 

 

You didn't read all of the post did you? :lol:

Bob Gibson would have to be.

Bob Gibson

Nolan Ryan.

Gibson & Koufax would be very tough to beat.

Bob Gibson hands down.

If you ask this question five years from now it may be Johnny Cueto.

There was a time I would of said Clemens, but not anymore. I'll go with someone I've actually seen pitch, Randy Johnson.

Bob Gibson hands down.

Agreed without a doubt...

Sandy Koufax

 

Although I can't remember watching Koufax, he would be my 2nd choice behind Gibson.

 

Ron Guidry, Don Gullet or Steve Carlton woud be other names that may come to mind.

I'll stick Bob Gibson though, the man defined the term "that's nasty" before it was a term.

If you ask this question five years from now it may be Johnny Cueto.

 

That would take alot more than 5 years to begin to match the longevity of some of the ones mentioned. Cueto is pretty good now but imo not even in the class (and probably will never be) of the likes of some mentioned in this thread.