Thanks @Colonels_Wear_Blue and everyone here are those 16 schools:

Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
Christian Academy of Louisville
Covington Catholic
DeSales
Holy Cross (Covington)
Holy Cross (Louisville)
Kentucky Country Day School
Lexington Catholic
Lexington Christian Academy
Newport Central Catholic
Owensboro Catholic
Saint Henry
Saint Xavier
Sayre School
Trinity (Louisville)

9 minutes ago, theguru said:

Thanks @Colonels_Wear_Blue and everyone here are those 16 schools:

Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
Christian Academy of Louisville
Covington Catholic
DeSales
Holy Cross (Covington)
Holy Cross (Louisville)
Kentucky Country Day School
Lexington Catholic
Lexington Christian Academy
Newport Central Catholic
Owensboro Catholic
Saint Henry
Saint Xavier
Sayre School
Trinity (Louisville)

So one possibility would be to have two private classes and I will break it down using my own opinion.

Top Class
Saint Xavier
Trinity
Covington Catholic
Christian Academy of Louisville
Lexington Catholic

Bottom Class
Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
DeSales
Covington Holy Cross
Louisville Holy Cross
Kentucky Country Day School
Lexington Christian Academy
Newport Central Catholic
Owensboro Catholic
Saint Henry
Sayre School

OR

Top Class
Saint Xavier
Trinity
Covington Catholic
Christian Academy of Louisville
Lexington Catholic
Lexington Christian Academy
Owensboro Catholic

Bottom Class
Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
DeSales
Covington Holy Cross
Louisville Holy Cross
Kentucky Country Day School
Newport Central Catholic
Saint Henry
Sayre School

33 minutes ago, theguru said:

So one possibility would be to have two private classes and I will break it down using my own opinion.

Top Class
Saint Xavier
Trinity
Covington Catholic
Christian Academy of Louisville
Lexington Catholic

Bottom Class
Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
DeSales
Covington Holy Cross
Louisville Holy Cross
Kentucky Country Day School
Lexington Christian Academy
Newport Central Catholic
Owensboro Catholic
Saint Henry
Sayre School

OR

Top Class
Saint Xavier
Trinity
Covington Catholic
Christian Academy of Louisville
Lexington Catholic
Lexington Christian Academy
Owensboro Catholic

Bottom Class
Bethlehem
Bishop Brossart
DeSales
Covington Holy Cross
Louisville Holy Cross
Kentucky Country Day School
Newport Central Catholic
Saint Henry
Sayre School

I would put DeSales in top class due to their size since bigger than all the lower class teams. They also beat St. X in 2018.

Boredom has got the best of me! With the recent decision in Alabama to spilt public and private schools, following suit with some other states, I wondered what if? What if Kentucky were to do the same. For sake of discussion let’s just use football. Rather than this be a should it happen or not happen, let’s say it hypothetically did happen. How would it work? By my count the state has 16 total private schools who participate in football. If you break that down by current alignment it’s a followed: 

1 A: (7) Bethlehem, Lou. Holy Cross, KCD, Newport Central Catholic, Bishop Brossert, Covington Holy Cross, and Sayre.

2A (3) Owensboro Catholic, Lexington Christian, and St. Henry.

3A (3) CAL, DeSales, and Lexington Catholic.

4A (1) Covington Catholic 

5A (0)

6A (2) Trinity, and St. Xavier 

How would you make this work? How many classes? What type of playoff format would you use? 
 

Again this is not should or shouldn’t happen, it’s what if it did. 
 

I personally see no way it’s possible based on the number of total teams and the size differences in the schools, but I’ll give it a stab. 2 classes, 8 schools in each. The 8 largest in division 1, the 8 smallest in division 2. You play a traditional 10 game schedule vs who ever you like. The playoffs are seeded 1-8 based on RPI,HS Rating etc 
 

Divsion 1 : Trinity, St. Xaiver, Covington Catholic, Lexington Catholic, DeSales, CAL, Lexington Catholic, and Owensboro Catholic. 
 

Division 2: Bethlehem, Lou. Holy Cross, KCD, Newport Central Catholic, Bishop Brossart, Covington Holy Cross, Sayre, and St. Henry. 
 

What say you? Hypothetically speaking of course?

8 minutes ago, Hogman said:

Boredom has got the best of me! With the recent decision in Alabama to spilt public and private schools, following suit with some other states, I wondered what if? What if Kentucky were to do the same. For sake of discussion let’s just use football. Rather than this be a should it happen or not happen, let’s say it hypothetically did happen. How would it work? By my count the state has 16 total private schools who participate in football. If you break that down by current alignment it’s a followed: 

1 A: (7) Bethlehem, Lou. Holy Cross, KCD, Newport Central Catholic, Bishop Brossert, Covington Holy Cross, and Sayre.

2A (3) Owensboro Catholic, Lexington Christian, and St. Henry.

3A (3) CAL, DeSales, and Lexington Catholic.

4A (1) Covington Catholic 

5A (0)

6A (2) Trinity, and St. Xavier 

How would you make this work? How many classes? What type of playoff format would you use? 
 

Again this is not should or shouldn’t happen, it’s what if it did. 
 

I personally see no way it’s possible based on the number of total teams and the size differences in the schools, but I’ll give it a stab. 2 classes, 8 schools in each. The 8 largest in division 1, the 8 smallest in division 2. You play a traditional 10 game schedule vs who ever you like. The playoffs are seeded 1-8 based on RPI,HS Rating etc 
 

Divsion 1 : Trinity, St. Xaiver, Covington Catholic, Lexington Catholic, DeSales, CAL, Lexington Catholic, and Owensboro Catholic. 
 

Division 2: Bethlehem, Lou. Holy Cross, KCD, Newport Central Catholic, Bishop Brossart, Covington Holy Cross, Sayre, and St. Henry. 
 

What say you? Hypothetically speaking of course?

I would drop Owensboro Catholic down to Division 2 and leave the rest where they're at. After doing this then people will complain about open public schools vs resides public schools. 

50 minutes ago, Tigerpride94 said:

I would drop Owensboro Catholic down to Division 2 and leave the rest where they're at. After doing this then people will complain about open public schools vs resides public schools. 

Right, if anything like a public/private split happens it won't be long before the "powers that be" come after Raceland, Pikeville, Beechwood, Mayfield, Belfry, Bell County, Highlands, Boyle County, Corbin, Owensboro, Woodford County, Pulaski County, Bowling Green, South Warren, Ryle, Frederick Douglass, Male, Manual, and on and on...  In short, if you are successful, the "mediocre masses" will come after you next. 

A suggestion I saw the other day I liked the most out of the split the privates talk. 
 

Put the top half of privates in 6A, the bottom half in 5A. Based on enrollment. 

7 minutes ago, DearToday said:

A suggestion I saw the other day I liked the most out of the split the privates talk. 
 

Put the top half of privates in 6A, the bottom half in 5A. Based on enrollment. 

So punish everyone not named T or X.

Bishop Brossart vs. Owensboro and Louisville Holy Cross vs. Bowling Green here we come!

4 minutes ago, theguru said:

So punish everyone not named T or X.

Bishop Brossart vs. Owensboro and Louisville Holy Cross vs. Bowling Green here we come!

Gee, I was so looking forward to Covington Holy Cross playing Trinity!  ?

9 minutes ago, nkypete said:

Gee, I was so looking forward to Covington Holy Cross playing Trinity!  ?

Nah, we will feed Covington Holy Cross to Pulaski County. 

50 minutes ago, theguru said:

So punish everyone not named T or X.

Bishop Brossart vs. Owensboro and Louisville Holy Cross vs. Bowling Green here we come!

I didn’t get that far ahead in my train of thought.. ?

Here we are 9 pages in and I still have no idea what the goal is. Who are we trying to help? What problem are we trying to fix?

And I will add, separating out 16 private schools is ludicrous. 

2 minutes ago, Voice of Reason said:

Here we are 9 pages in and I still have no idea what the goal is. Who are we trying to help? What problem are we trying to fix?

I asked Google what to do with a crying adult:

Dealing with a "crybaby" adult—someone who frequently complains about minor issues, avoids responsibility, or uses emotional outbursts to get their way—requires a combination of firm boundaries, emotional validation, and, in some cases, disengagement. Key approaches include setting clear limits on behavior, encouraging self-reliance, and not enabling the behavior with excessive attention. 

4 minutes ago, Voice of Reason said:

And I will add, separating out 16 private schools is ludicrous. 

This.

43 minutes ago, theguru said:

This.

Agreed but I’m going to play along.

Have an “Open” class with the largest schools by Male enrollment. This would include St X and T and ANY other school that wanted to compete in it.

All other Private schools in one class. Once your schools Male enrollment reaches ??? you go into the Open class.

All other Classes are enrollment only but only 4 classes. 
 

Open 

4a

3a

Private

2a

1a