What is your favorite Pop-Tart flavor?

[Jumper_Dad]

Not a big fan of them, but S'Mores would be my top choice.

 

What's yours?

 

S'Mores is a great change up, love them with coffee.

[catholicdude]

Cherry is my favorite. Does anyone else eat the outside "crust" first?

[sportsfan41]

S'mores and it's not even close. I could eat a strawberry if I had to.

[lottoman89]

S'mores for me also.

[mcpapa]

Cherry is my favorite. Does anyone else eat the outside "crust" first?

We could be separated at birth. Of course you eat the crust first. Delayed gratification, save the best for last, well- developed ego strength - take your pick.

[mcpapa]

And let’s take it a step further. I really don’t like changing the subject - particularly given the import of pop tart preference.

 

But doesn’t pretty much everyone, given an even number of Oreos, take the tops off of two of them, eat them plain, and create one Super Oreo to savor? Heck, they had to make Double Stuff Oreos because of this very practice.

[gchs_uk9]

1. Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon

2. Frosted Strawberry

 

Used to like frosted cinnamon (pink frosting with red flecks) but haven’t had one in forever.

 

I’ll add: I don’t toast them.

Edited June 3, 2020 by gchs_uk9

[PP1]

I like the original Cherry, with no frosting or sprinkles, and not toasted.

[catholicdude]

And let’s take it a step further. I really don’t like changing the subject - particularly given the import of pop tart preference.

 

But doesn’t pretty much everyone, given an even number of Oreos, take the tops off of two of them, eat them plain, and create one Super Oreo to savor? Heck, they had to make Double Stuff Oreos because of this very practice.

 

Double Stuff are the only ones we buy! My daughter taught me the trick of sticking a fork in them so you can submerge the whole thing in milk or coffee without getting your fingers messy.

[Irish Cat]

And let’s take it a step further. I really don’t like changing the subject - particularly given the import of pop tart preference.

 

But doesn’t pretty much everyone, given an even number of Oreos, take the tops off of two of them, eat them plain, and create one Super Oreo to savor? Heck, they had to make Double Stuff Oreos because of this very practice.

 

Your showing your age. Double Stuff Oreos were introduced in 1975. As that predates my ability to eat solid foods, I never had to resort to such archaic practices.

[BFritz]

Before I hit a tree, I was all about brown cinnamon (and I used to like them better when I didn't heat them up), but now I'm a toasted strawberry guy!

[OlDog75]

Brown Sugar Cinnamon.

 

Fyi Strawberry and BSC are #1 and #2 sellers.

 

My favorite also, non iced though.

[brown4]

Brown Sugar Cinnamon and Cherry are 1A and 1B for me. But has anyone ever tried the Chocolate Fudge Pop Tarts after putting them in a freezer? Total game changer.

[jvdfc]

1. Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon

2. Frosted Strawberry

[WESTSIDE]

Brown Sugar Cinnamon