November 19, 200619 yr The new BCS standings just came out, and Michigan retained their hold on 2nd place. With U of M holding on w/ a loss, could they drop in the standings when they don't even play?
November 19, 200619 yr ^Yes, they could drop considering there are likely two top-ten vs. top-ten matchups left... Notre Dame at USC, Arkansas vs. Florida in the Georgia Dome. A rematch is looking more likely than ever, but with the Coaches' Poll lifting USC over Michigan, a win over the Irish could easily knock them over the top. A convincing win by Florida or Arkansas might get it done... but it doesn't seem very likely.
November 19, 200619 yr http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/football/ncaa/polls/bcs/ BCS Standings - November 19, 2006 1) Ohio St 2) Michigan 3) USC 4) Florida 5) Notre Dame 9) Louisville 14) Rutgers 5 SEC Teams in the Top 25
November 19, 200619 yr I know I've never said this before. GO IRISH!!! :banana: Are you ok? How bad did that hurt?:lol:
November 19, 200619 yr I know it's unlikely but I feel that if ND beats USC next Saturday they deserve to play Ohio St. for the national title.
November 19, 200619 yr If everything stays the same, is it fair that OSU must beat UM to win the title, considering they just beat them?
November 19, 200619 yr If everything stays the same, is it fair that OSU must beat UM to win the title, considering they just beat them? Happens all the time in b-ball. Why is football different?
November 19, 200619 yr I know it's unlikely but I feel that if ND beats USC next Saturday they deserve to play Ohio St. for the national title. Ohio State would embarrass them again...
November 19, 200619 yr Ohio State would embarrass them again... To embarrass them again they have to embarrass them a first time...
November 19, 200619 yr If everything stays the same, is it fair that OSU must beat UM to win the title, considering they just beat them? I don't understand this argument. I heard or read someone today say that this game was like a semi-final game and Michigan blew their chance. Actually, it was a regular season game between the best two teams in the country. No more, no less. There's no way possible that anyone could justify the best team in the country (O$U), playing the 3rd best team in the country (presumably U$C) and calling it the National Championship. I said this before and no one responded. They say home field advantage in college football is worth 3-4 points. A neutral sight matchup is the only way to go...
November 19, 200619 yr To embarrass them again they have to embarrass them a first time... I think he's talking about last year. I must say that I am surprised. Even though it was a great close game, it is very unusual of the pollsters to only drop a team one spot when teams behind them won. Not saying it is wrong, but it is highly unusual.
November 19, 200619 yr It must be great to be Michigan. You lose to the only good team in your league and finish second in a league in which your other 9 members lose 28 of their 29 games against teams ranked in the top 25. The teams on your schedule have combined to win 3 out of 27 games against ranked opponents. The 3 big wins are Vandy beating #16 Georgia (now out of the top 25), ND beating #19 Penn St (now out of the top 25) and Indiana beating #15 Iowa ( now out of the top 25). Still you remain the consensus #2 pick in the BCS. Michigan has beaten noone who has beaten noone but because they are #2 in the BIG TEN they supposedly are head and shoulders above everyone else. Sorry but if you aren't #1 in your conference you are not entitled to play for the NC period. Close only counts in horseshoes.
November 19, 200619 yr It must be great to be Michigan. You lose to the only good team in your league and finish second in a league in which your other 9 members lose 28 of their 29 games against teams ranked in the top 25. The teams on your schedule have combined to win 3 out of 27 games against ranked opponents. The 3 big wins are Vandy beating #16 Georgia (now out of the top 25), ND beating #19 Penn St (now out of the top 25) and Indiana beating #15 Iowa ( now out of the top 25). Still you remain the consensus #2 pick in the BCS. Michigan has beaten noone who has beaten noone but because they are #2 in the BIG TEN they supposedly are head and shoulders above everyone else. Sorry but if you aren't #1 in your conference you are not entitled to play for the NC period. So if the two best teams are in the same conference they'll never play for the National Championship? Also, didn't they beat ND badly? Ya know what, if they say Notre Dame can never win a National Championship because they won't win a conference title I may agree with you.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.