I think you just argued the wrong side...

 

 

Not at all...What I have been saying all along is we could do this all night and nobody would be right.

I just got back from Highlands and the rumours are flying. There were 2 lawyers in our group who said that the appeals judge who ruled against Mitchell today was from Boyle land. There are 2 Northern Ky appeals judges and it wasn't one of them. i can't believe Smith would stoop so low. Go Birds :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

 

You oughta be mad at Dale. I can't believe people are blaming anyone but him.

And yet another black eye in this mess.

 

By the way congrats on 900 Ram 95. :dancingpa

Whoops! Wrong Ram! Mr. I'm A Fancy Moderator Ram 95 has about a billion posts. I'm nowhere near him!

Good night all. I'll check tomorrow for some reason I think this will still be pretty active.

I like the new state championship shirts... Highlands High School Football "Cheat to Win!"

If they had used an ineligible pllayer. But at no time did Mitchell play when his legal status was "ineligible." The courts said he was eligible at the time he played the games and that's the way it should stand.

 

Thank you for replying in a rational manner. Why would Highlands have to forfeit the regular season wins then?

I think, with the coach knowing the situation and the possibilities and the history of this transfer rule of sitting out one year, that COACH MUELLER made the absolute worst decision possible, and he has to receive the majority of the blame.

What was Mueller suppose to do???? The court said he could play so he let him play. Now the court says he can't play so Mueller won't play him until this gets overturned again by the end of the week. If I was Mitchell's dad and a court said my son could play and Mueller wouldn't play him I would sue Highlands. What was Mueller suppose to do??????? :mad: :mad: :mad:

I just got back from Highlands and the rumours are flying. There were 2 lawyers in our group who said that the appeals judge who ruled against Mitchell today was from Boyle land. There are 2 Northern Ky appeals judges and it wasn't one of them. i can't believe Smith would stoop so low. Go Birds :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

You yourself said these are rumors, so you go out on limb and blame Smith for something that I'm sure he had nothing to do with or at least none of us would know if he did. I'm sure he has been practicing all week and watching film in hopes to win instead of being on the phone with a laywer.

Whoops! Wrong Ram! Mr. I'm A Fancy Moderator Ram 95 has about a billion posts. I'm nowhere near him!

 

 

The bad part was I knew that and still put that down.

 

You got the ideal.

 

Once again Congrats. :dancingpa

I like the new state championship shirts... Highlands High School Football "Cheat to Win!"

Now, like I said, while I don't think it would be fair to allow Highlands to continue to play, it's also unfair to call Highlands cheaters.

If they had used an ineligible pllayer. But at no time did Mitchell play when his legal status was "ineligible." The courts said he was eligible at the time he played the games and that's the way it should stand.

 

Not so, BF.

 

The temporary injunction did give the OK for Mitchell to play, but was subject to be overturned by the higher court. Which happened and which also means that the injuction was never valid. So we revert back to the original KHSAA ruling of ineligibility as the prevailing ruling on the case.

 

These risks were known going in.

I like the new state championship shirts... Highlands High School Football "Cheat to Win!"

:lol: :lol:

I've asked it once and I'll ask it again. Does the KHSAA ever, EVER, consider these kids? :confused:

 

Did the Coach?

....Bring in Judge Judy, either way he is still ineligable, and that's the bottom line.

The fight is still not over :madman: :madman: :madman:

What was Mueller suppose to do???? The court said he could play so he let him play. Now the court says he can't play so Mueller won't play him until this gets overturned again by the end of the week. If I was Mitchell's dad and a court said my son could play and Mueller wouldn't play him I would sue Highlands. What was Mueller suppose to do??????? :mad: :mad: :mad:

It was more complicated than that and both parties knew it. Mueller knew the whole time that the if the appeals were overturned this could happen and both parties knew the appeals would keep coming so it was a huge caculated risk. Also I would like to see where a court would favor an upset dad over a prominent coach who doesn't want to jeopardize his team.