BW plays a very good pre-1A schedule. SO if a college coach wants game film from good competition there is plenty of it.

Their best game is Cov, who until last year and this coming season has been down. I disagree with the good competition statement. They play a good schedule for a IA school. They don't play what I would call a highly competative regional schedule that pits your athletes against the kind of competition that they would face at the highest college level.

I honestly don't understand why you would go to Beechwood anymore strictly for football. They are A, which means the competition you play week in and week out is low. They haven't been getting the job accomplished lately at the state level in that classification. Division I coaches look at a player vs. their best competition. You are much more likely to get the desired looks playing at a larger school that has sucess. Of course, Beechwood does have many other benefits to offer. However, their benefits do not exceed Highlands or Ryle academically. Once again, I am not trying to insult Beechwood. I am just making the point that I feel there would be more reasons than football to transfer to Beechwood at this moment in their program.

 

The biggest attaction to Beechwood (over schools like Ryle, Cov. Cath, and Highlands) would be the ability to play every down of every play, while still playing for a top program. While there maybe a few every down players at Ryle or even Cov. Cath, my guess is that Beechwood would have more, as would, NCC and Holy Crosss.

 

I do think the schedule is very unattractive at Beechwood.

You sir are grossly misinformed.

 

How so? Which IA high school plays a big boy schedule in this state? Please correct me if I am wrong? Do they play highly competative 6A schools? Do they play state contender 4 and 5 A schools? The answer on that could be yes with Cov depending on the year. Do they play high level regional schools from other states? There is a difference between a high level schedule and a high level A schedule.

Their best game is Cov, who until last year and this coming season has been down. I disagree with the good competition statement. They play a good schedule for a IA school. They don't play what I would call a highly competative regional schedule that pits your athletes against the kind of competition that they would face at the highest college level.

 

A marquee game at Beechwood is very different than a marquee game at some of the better biggers schools (Ryle, Cov. Cath., and Highlands)

The biggest attaction to Beechwood (over schools like Ryle, Cov. Cath, and Highlands) would be the ability to play every down of every play, while still playing for a top program. While there maybe a few every down players at Ryle or even Cov. Cath, my guess is that Beechwood would have more, as would, NCC and Holy Crosss.

 

I do think the schedule is very unattractive at Beechwood.

 

I can follow that line of thinking if you are concerned about playing both ways.

How so? Which IA high school plays a big boy schedule in this state? Please correct me if I am wrong? Do they play highly competative 6A schools? Do they play state contender 4 and 5 A schools? The answer on that could be yes with Cov depending on the year. Do they play high level regional schools from other states? There is a difference between a high level schedule and a high level A schedule.

You are wrong about D1 Recruiting. I have spoken with quit a few DI, DII, DIII, and NAIA coaches and they could care less what size high school you played for. They are professionals and feel that they are able to gauge talent and determine if a player is good enough to play for them. If fact, I have had several college coaches tell me that if they had boys playing football in high school, they would send them to a small school so they could play earlier and get more experience prior to their senior year.

You are wrong about D1 Recruiting. I have spoken with quit a few DI, DII, DIII, and NAIA coaches and they could care less what size high school you played for. They are professionals and feel that they are able to gauge talent and determine if a player is good enough to play for them. If fact, I have had several college coaches tell me that if they had boys playing football in high school, they would send them to a small school so they could play earlier and get more experience prior to their senior year.

 

I have also talked to several DI coaches who claim they don't care about the size of the school a kid plays at, but have openly admitted that film of regional powers gets looked at by a much larger number of DI schools across the country. Also, they seem to go against their word when every time they are looking at a kid they look at his teams schedule and ask for the game film against their absolute best opponents. If that best opponent is Cov with a seven win record, that is not a lot of competition. If that opponent is Cincy St.X or another DI Ohio Power, the look is better. Also, like I said up top, you will get more looks through schools looking at a regional power that you have played that has DI talent being looked at within its ranks. It is really a dream to think playing better competition doesn't open more doors.

WOW. You asked a question . I answered it. You take offense. What happened? Condescending? Relax, Chief. I answered your darn question. You keep saying there are no differences and say "different rules on students attending?" and I answered it.

 

Boone has different rules than BW and other independents. You didn't mention anything about State BOE.

 

You are correct. Boone Schools made their own rule which, again, we've established.

 

Post #78 and post #81 in this thread both referred to STATE rules. We have run a simple question through two pages of posts. All I want is a simple, direct answer. If you don't know, say you don't know. No problem.

 

I will try one more time.

 

By state Board of Education rules, is there any difference between out of district students eligibility to enroll at a county district versus an independent district?

 

That is an open question to anyone on here, not just Clyde.

Post #78 and post #81 in this thread both referred to STATE rules. We have run a simple question through two pages of posts. All I want is a simple, direct answer. If you don't know, say you don't know. No problem.

 

I will try one more time.

 

By state Board of Education rules, is there any difference between out of district students eligibility to enroll at a county district versus an independent district?

 

.

 

Already answered.

Maybe an even more incendiary thread title would be :

 

"Could Beechwood Football Survive without out of district transfers and enrollments?"

 

Yes, and contend for state titles.

 

Now let me ask you an incendiary question right back -

 

If Simon Kenton kept all their talent, would Simon Kenton have a winning record every year?

I have also talked to several DI coaches who claim they don't care about the size of the school a kid plays at, but have openly admitted that film of regional powers gets looked at by a much larger number of DI schools across the country. Also, they seem to go against their word when every time they are looking at a kid they look at his teams schedule and ask for the game film against their absolute best opponents. If that best opponent is Cov with a seven win record, that is not a lot of competition. If that opponent is Cincy St.X or another DI Ohio Power, the look is better. Also, like I said up top, you will get more looks through schools looking at a regional power that you have played that has DI talent being looked at within its ranks. It is really a dream to think playing better competition doesn't open more doors.

I guess we just have different experiences then.

I may miss someone, but to my knowledge:

 

Varsity 2-Layne and Ft M resident Justice

JV 3-Brightx2 and Hamilton

Frosh-2 Stringer and Hermes

 

For you, how many kids on the SK roster that are Open Enroll kids?

 

For clarification purposes, Lane and Hamilton are both Ft. Mitchell residents.

Already answered.

 

:lol: Where? I missed it.

 

And if you can't find it, chalk that post up as another patronizing one by you. I just don't get why you can't answer a direct question.

They do have different rules than some other school districts.

 

It's just not different in the eyes of the KHSAA.

 

:lol: Where? I missed it.

 

And if you can't find it, chalk that post up as another patronizing one by you. I just don't get why you can't answer a direct question.

 

Here you go. Not sure why this is suddenly getting personal.

For clarification purposes, Lane and Hamilton are both Ft. Mitchell residents.

 

Thanks for clarifying. I think that leaves exactly zero non Ft. Mitchell residents on the current varsity.