May 6, 201115 yr I guess my wife and I are the only people that can't stand Haley. I'm not a fan either. She seems to have an attitude.
May 6, 201115 yr Author I'm not a fan either. She seems to have an attitude. I get the exact impression. She seems to have a very "whatever, it's cool" attitude. Now Jacob had a diva attitude!
May 12, 201115 yr Another great night of performances by all 4. James--After last week and the challenge of keeping his emontions in check, James came out as the powerful performer already on tour! I enjoyed both prformances. Scotty--Great night for Scotty--although not as good as last week. Ballad very good but a little boring. 2nd song kind of seemed pushed, and like he was forcing the theatrics part. He just did not seem to be so comfortable tonight. Lauren--beautful job, she was most improved for the night. I did not enjoy her second song as much as the first. But she is pushing herself to reach those big notes. Hailey--nice job on the second song. I just do not care for her personality as a performer. She does not connect well with the audienece like the other 3. When she sings and when she is interviewed, I think she lacks the passion. Lady GaGa---despise her!
May 12, 201115 yr Haley needs to go after her attitude last night. I thought Randy was dead on with his thoughts on her performance. The other 3 were head and shoulders better and very even too. Could have done without Lady Gaga.
May 12, 201115 yr Haley's voice runs through me like a knife....I've heard Janis Joplin sing and Haley ain't no Janis!!! She does not strike me as someone who has the makings of being a star....I thought she acted like a total little jerk last night......:irked: Scotty and Lauren are both great singers and I enjoy listening to both of them.... James.....James has the whole package...he can sing anything that they throw at him and does a great job each time....I do think this kid is a star and I look forward to seeing what he does with the rest of his life!!!!!:clap::clap::clap:
May 12, 201115 yr First off I am actually a GaGa fan. I think James is good but as I posted earlier, please stop doing the scream in EVERY song.
May 12, 201115 yr I get the exact impression. She seems to have a very "whatever, it's cool" attitude. Now Jacob had a diva attitude! Yeah, she seems really stuck on herself. That was pretty clear last night. I think tonight might be her last. Haley needs to go after her attitude last night. I thought Randy was dead on with his thoughts on her performance. The other 3 were head and shoulders better and very even too. Could have done without Lady Gaga.:thumb:
May 13, 201115 yr That was absolutely the WORST, most pathetic result in the history of American Idol!! :madman: The only thing that makes it a little better, is the knowledge that James (like Chris Daughtery) will end up the biggest star of the bunch anyway. The show won't be worth watching from this point forward. :irked: Haley (who was visibly smiling during James' farewell song) should have been sent packing.
May 13, 201115 yr That was absolutely the WORST, most pathetic result in the history of American Idol!! :madman: The only thing that makes it a little better, is the knowledge that James (like Chris Daughtery) will end up the biggest star of the bunch anyway. The show won't be worth watching from this point forward. :irked: Haley (who was visibly smiling during James' farewell song) should have been sent packing. I noticed that also. I guess her good looks carried her to another round. She is by far the worst of the 4! I agree with you that James will be a big star but I also think Scotty and Lauren will be big in the country music world. Don't know what Haley will do but I do know she should have went home!
May 13, 201115 yr I agree with you that James will be a big star but I also think Scotty and Lauren will be big in the country music world.Yes, they definitely will.
May 13, 201115 yr Author This will have zero impact on James' career. In some ways it could be a positive especially in the niche he'll be in.
May 13, 201115 yr That was absolutely the WORST, most pathetic result in the history of American Idol!! :madman: The only thing that makes it a little better, is the knowledge that James (like Chris Daughtery) will end up the biggest star of the bunch anyway. The show won't be worth watching from this point forward. :irked: Haley (who was visibly smiling during James' farewell song) should have been sent packing. STUNNED!! Just learning all this now. Taped the show, did not realize the 2 hr part so missed the results in th second hour. WOW!! Just got finished watching the first half. Kept thinking how much I LOVE watching James perform anything---from Journey to his duet with Scotty!! I agree--why watch it now? Except that I do really like Lauren and Scotty. What were the judges' reactions when James did not make the top 3?
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.