September 10, 200917 yr Taking over Paula Abdul's spot. http://tv.yahoo.com/american-idol/show/34934/news/tv.accesshollywood.com/ellen-degeneres-named-new-american-idol-judge-20090909
September 10, 200917 yr This is a good choice. She is funny, loves music and should be a fairly positive judge. She will also sound coherent when giving criticisms and that is a plus!
September 10, 200917 yr I think this will spell the beginning of the end for AI, it has already ran over 8-9 seasons.
September 10, 200917 yr This is a good choice. She is funny, loves music and should be a fairly positive judge. She will also sound coherent when giving criticisms and that is a plus! Agree. I love Ellen!
September 10, 200917 yr This is a good choice. She is funny, loves music and should be a fairly positive judge. She will also sound coherent when giving criticisms and that is a plus! I think she is a terrible choice. What kind of music back ground does she have? How can she be expected to critique people's music when she'll have no idea what she is talking about. She might be good for a few laughs at the very beginning of the show, but I don't see what she brings to the table when it gets serious.
September 10, 200917 yr I think she is a terrible choice. What kind of music back ground does she have? How can she be expected to critique people's music when she'll have no idea what she is talking about. She might be good for a few laughs at the very beginning of the show, but I don't see what she brings to the table when it gets serious. It is about entertainment waayyyy more than anything else.
September 10, 200917 yr This is a good choice. She is funny, loves music and should be a fairly positive judge. She will also sound coherent when giving criticisms and that is a plus! I was thinking the same thing....... Later.
September 10, 200917 yr It is about entertainment waayyyy more than anything else. Then get rid of Randy Jackson, and bring Seinfeld on as a judge.
September 10, 200917 yr I think she is a terrible choice. What kind of music back ground does she have? How can she be expected to critique people's music when she'll have no idea what she is talking about. She might be good for a few laughs at the very beginning of the show, but I don't see what she brings to the table when it gets serious.:thumb: :thumb:
September 10, 200917 yr Who cares, this show is awful and needs to go away anyways. There are obviously several million people that disagree with you, or Fox wouldn't renew the show every year.
September 10, 200917 yr Paula was nice to look at when sober :0).....should have brought in a looker!
September 10, 200917 yr Who cares, this show is awful and needs to go away anyways.:thumb: A bad show just got worse.
September 10, 200917 yr I think she is a terrible choice. What kind of music back ground does she have? How can she be expected to critique people's music when she'll have no idea what she is talking about. She might be good for a few laughs at the very beginning of the show, but I don't see what she brings to the table when it gets serious. :thumb:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.