August 21, 200719 yr :lol: Career totals from 2003-2005 444-completions, 718-attempts, 6,040-yards, 44-TD, 28-INT While Matt Leinart did this from 2003-2005 807-completions, 1245-attempts, 10693-yards, 99-TD's, 23-INT's Flat out who's the better QB? No Way Vince is better than Leinart in college, and no way is he the best college football player ever, IMO not even in the top 10. Where are Young's rushing stats???
August 21, 200719 yr Tough question to try and narrow it down. Do you vote your favorite? The best you think you saw? Offense and/or Defense? Favorite Offense: Earl Campbell, Texas Defense: Art Still, Kentucky Best Offense: Reggie Bush, USC (He could break it anytime, anywhere) Defense: Hugh Green, Pitt (Dominated teams from DE/LB) These are some I thought no one else would list and I thought qualify for discussion. I just gotta say that Earl Campell is my all time favorite football player. I thought about him but I just think Sanders is the best.
August 21, 200719 yr Where are Young's rushing stats??? 457-attempts, 3,127-yards, 6.8-avg, 37-TD's Still doesn't make him the BEST college play EVER, and anyone who says so hasn't checked the stats of every player to play college football.
August 21, 200719 yr Off the top of my head... OJ Simpson, Marcus Allen, Paul Hornung, Tim Brown, Vince Young, Reggie Bush, Brian Brohm (), The Four Horsemen, Roger Staubach, Barry Sanders, Ricky Williams
August 21, 200719 yr This is more of my favorite then best ever but one of the biggest clutch, big game pressure QB's of the last 25 years was Tommie Frazier. That guy just had the will to win and was a monster from 92-95. Undefeated and 2 national titles in his last two years, he was just dominate during that span and beat the snot out of a lot of highly ranked teams. Eddie George stole the heisman from him. Here's a little refresher for people who dont remember his play. He was one of the first to come to mind to me, but I didn't pick him cause being a Nebraska fan that would had been a homer call:D None the less i think Griffith was the best closely followed by Sanders and the one and only Tyler Rose.
August 21, 200719 yr Off the top of my head... OJ Simpson, Marcus Allen, Paul Hornung, Tim Brown, Vince Young, Reggie Bush, Brian Brohm (), The Four Horsemen, Roger Staubach, Barry Sanders, Ricky Williams IMO arguably the best college QB ever.
August 21, 200719 yr Hard to find one... OJ Simpson Vince Young Peter Warrick Reggie Bush Tim Couch Payton Manning Ricky Williams Barry Sanders Deion Sanders
August 21, 200719 yr Red Grange (how could people not mention this guy???) Hershal Walker Sammy Baugh George Gipp Dick Butkus Bronko Nagurski Jim Thorpe OJ Barry Sanders Jim Brown Doak Walker Paul Hornung Roger Staubach
August 21, 200719 yr Vince Young is not even in the top 25......... No particular order... Barry Sanders (Oklahoma State) Herschel Walker (Georgia) Tony Dorsett (Pittsburgh) Bo Jackson (Auburn) Earl Campbell (Texas) Marshall Faulk (San Diego State) Billy Sims (Oklahoma) Eddie George (Ohio State) Archie Griffin (Ohio State) Charles Woodson (Michigan) Ricky Williams (Texas) Brian Bosworth (Oklahoma) Marcus Allen (USC) Lawrence Taylor (North Carolina) Vinny Testaverde (Miami (FL)) Lee Roy Selmon (Oklahoma) Desmond Howard (Michigan) Raghib "Rocket" Ismael (Notre Dame) Orlando Pace (Ohio State) Doug Flutie (Boston College) Ty Detmer (BYU) Charlie Ward (Florida State) Roger Staubach (Navy) Jim Plunkett (Stanford) Tommie Frazier (Nebraska) Michael Vick (Virginia Tech) Charles White (USC) Ron Dayne (Wisconsin) Tim Brown (Notre Dame) Hugh Green (Pittsburgh) Peyton Manning (Tennessee) Franco Harris (Penn State) Danny Wuerffel (Florida) Rashaan Salaam (Colorado) Bob Gain (Kentucky) O.J. Simpson (USC) Alan Ameche (Wisconsin) Philip Rivers (North Carolina State)
August 21, 200719 yr Willie "Smokin" Totten QB Miss. Valley St. (Current MVSU Head Coach) Coached by Archie "Gunslinger" Cooley (Retired) Some Rice kid was his top receiver was his top receiver (I wonder what ever happened to him?)
August 21, 200719 yr OJ Simpson Herschel Walker Bo Jackson Barry Sanders A few players from KY that may not have been the best ever but certainly were exciting to watch as any I have seen would be...... Derek Abney Craig Yeast Marty Moore
August 21, 200719 yr Vince Young is not even in the top 25......... No particular order... Barry Sanders (Oklahoma State) Herschel Walker (Georgia) Tony Dorsett (Pittsburgh) Bo Jackson (Auburn) Earl Campbell (Texas) Marshall Faulk (San Diego State) Billy Sims (Oklahoma) Eddie George (Ohio State) Archie Griffin (Ohio State) Charles Woodson (Michigan) Ricky Williams (Texas) Brian Bosworth (Oklahoma) Marcus Allen (USC) Lawrence Taylor (North Carolina) Vinny Testaverde (Miami (FL)) Lee Roy Selmon (Oklahoma) Desmond Howard (Michigan) Raghib "Rocket" Ismael (Notre Dame) Orlando Pace (Ohio State) Doug Flutie (Boston College) Ty Detmer (BYU) Charlie Ward (Florida State) Roger Staubach (Navy) Jim Plunkett (Stanford) Tommie Frazier (Nebraska) Michael Vick (Virginia Tech) Charles White (USC) Ron Dayne (Wisconsin) Tim Brown (Notre Dame) Hugh Green (Pittsburgh) Peyton Manning (Tennessee) Franco Harris (Penn State) Danny Wuerffel (Florida) Rashaan Salaam (Colorado) Bob Gain (Kentucky) O.J. Simpson (USC) Alan Ameche (Wisconsin) Philip Rivers (North Carolina State) I don't think Michael Vick is in the top 25 either. If you can justify putting him in there then there is no way Vince Young is left out, he won a National Championship. I'd have to question Phillip Rivers too.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.