Who was the better High School running back. Both took their respective schools to the state championship but came up empty. Alexander was a fantastic defensive player as well.

Miles Simpson had 93 total Tds.

Miles Simpson had 93 total Tds.

 

More points career. Alexander

More points season. Alexander

More points single game. Alexander.

More career TDs. Alexander.

More TDs season. Alexander

More TDs Game. Alexander

 

I'm sensing a pattern...

That was a quick argument haha. Alexander hands down.

Just looked it up Alexander had 6,657 rushing yards and 110 Tds.

But I guarantee Alexander had at least a couple 100 rushes more than Simpson.

I'm a fan of Simpson but it's Alexander and I don't even think it's close.

Alexander , It's not even close .

Alexander , It's not even close .

 

I agree all Boone County does is run the ball. SK passes just as much as they run.

:lol:....Not this crap again!!!!

I think they were very similar backs, except Alexander was a bit bigger, more durable (in HS). Alexander wasn't a bruiser by any means but Simpson appeared to be a bit more fragile. Alexander was a better back but Simpson could fly to the ball defensively.

Miles was Good,Shaun was Great.

This will be on the next ESPN addition of "COME ON MAN", this is not even a comparison. Alexander (NFL MVP). Once Simpson has any type of success in college, or becomes NFL MVP then repost. Alexander had over 3,000 yards his senior year alone. I like Simpson and he was a very good high school back, but not on the same level as Alexander.

I agree all Boone County does is run the ball. SK passes just as much as they run.

 

Which is actually another very good reason why Alexander was a far better back than Simpson.

Really, this is a question?

 

Alexander for all the reasons mentioned above. Oh, and nearly every school in the country wanted him to come play running back. College coaches must have thought he was better as well.