September 24, 200917 yr My son and I was watching Joe Buck Live this week and his guests were John Elway, Joe Namath, and Dan Marino. They discussed the best QB's ever and this caused a discussion between my son and I about the top 10 pro QB's in our opinion. This is my list. Lets hear yours!! 1. Joe Montana 2.John Elway 3.Roger Staubach 4.Terry Bradshaw 5.Johnny Unitas 6.Fran Tarkenton 7.Steve Young 8.Dan Marino 9.Peyton Manning 10.Bret Favre
September 24, 200917 yr Some others that should be considered... Bart Starr Otto Graham Tom Brady Sammy Baugh
September 25, 200917 yr Author Some others that should be considered... Bart Starr Otto Graham Tom Brady Sammy Baugh Those are some good ones. I also didnt mention Kenny Stabler or Len Dawson.
September 25, 200917 yr Marino looks much younger than Elway, he's aged well. All I can think of when I see Namath is him asking Suzie if he could give her a kiss.
September 25, 200917 yr First QB to throw for 4000 yards in a season and this was a 14 game season? Yeah, Namath has to be mentioned in this thread also. What years did he play for Bama???
September 25, 200917 yr My thing with Favre is that, yes he's broke a ton of records, but he's also taken a lot longer to break them. Better QB's made those records with shorter seasons and not playing as long. I agree with him being around 9 or 10 but I'd question putting him any higher.
September 25, 200917 yr Yeah, Namath has to be mentioned in this thread also. What years did he play for Bama??? 1961-64
September 25, 200917 yr My son and I was watching Joe Buck Live this week and his guests were John Elway, Joe Namath, and Dan Marino. They discussed the best QB's ever and this caused a discussion between my son and I about the top 10 pro QB's in our opinion. This is my list. Lets hear yours!! 1. Joe Montana 2.John Elway 3.Roger Staubach 4.Terry Bradshaw 5.Johnny Unitas 6.Fran Tarkenton 7.Steve Young 8.Dan Marino 9.Peyton Manning 10.Bret Favre I don't think Bradshaw is a #4 if a top 10. I would rather have Brady over Manning. Favre is a great QB but he is to dangerous for me. I don't know enough about some of them to judge since they were before my time. Just from what I have seen , Marino is the greatest QB without a Super bowl.
September 25, 200917 yr Author I don't think Bradshaw is a #4 if a top 10. I would rather have Brady over Manning. Favre is a great QB but he is to dangerous for me. I don't know enough about some of them to judge since they were before my time. Just from what I have seen , Marino is the greatest QB without a Super bowl. My reasoning on putting Bradshaw that high was that he simply won games and Super Bowls. Granted he was throwing to some of the best ever in Swan, Stallworth, Franco, Bennie Cunningham, etc. but he sailed the ship and they were winners!
September 25, 200917 yr Author First QB to throw for 4000 yards in a season and this was a 14 game season? Namath wasnt an oversight on my list and I knew a lot of people would disagree. I just didnt think he was a top 10 QB all time. However I know that you can make a very solid argument for him. Just my humble opinion!!
September 25, 200917 yr There's no way I would have a top ten list with Peyton Manning in it, and without Tom Brady.
September 25, 200917 yr There's no way I would have a top ten list with Peyton Manning in it, and without Tom Brady. I think they both should be in the top 10.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.