January 14, 200917 yr Possibly, but not right now. Now if he can get a ring and continue to play on a high level for the next 4-5 years I think he's a lock.
January 14, 200917 yr I liked him a lot when he played for Syracuse too, so when he got drafted by Philly I decided I was going to be a fan of them too.
January 14, 200917 yr They were saying that McNabb's numbers were comparable, with the obvious exception of rings, with those of Aikman and Young; and that in 2-3 more years, McNabb would obliterate those numbers. Would Aikman have ever been there without those rings. I would say noway! Should he be there? Yes! I believe they picked the wrong guys to make comparisons.
January 14, 200917 yr These 2 are very comparable. McNabb - Passing 10 year Career 5 time pro-Bowler; 9-5 career Postseason G ATT Com Com% A/G Y Avg Y/G TD TD% Int Int% Rate 134 4,303 2,534 58.9 32.1 29,320 6.8 218.8 194 4.5 90 2.1 85.9 McNabb - Rushing G A Y Avg TD 134 536 3,109 5.8 26 Ken Anderson - Passing 4 time Pro-Bowl, 1 time 1st team All-Pro; 4 time passing leader G Att Com Comp% Att/Game Y AVG Y/G TD TD % INT INT% Rate 192 4475 2654 59.3 23.3 32,838 7.3 171 197 4.4 160 3.6 81.9 Ken Anderson Rushing 2-4 Career postseason G Att Yards Avg TD 192 397 2220 5.6 20
January 14, 200917 yr These 2 are very comparable. McNabb - Passing 10 year Career 5 time pro-Bowler; 9-5 career Postseason G ATT Com Com% A/G Y Avg Y/G TD TD% Int Int% Rate 134 4,303 2,534 58.9 32.1 29,320 6.8 218.8 194 4.5 90 2.1 85.9 McNabb - Rushing G A Y Avg TD 134 536 3,109 5.8 26 Ken Anderson - Passing 4 time Pro-Bowl, 1 time 1st team All-Pro; 4 time passing leader G Att Com Comp% Att/Game Y AVG Y/G TD TD % INT INT% Rate 192 4475 2654 59.3 23.3 32,838 7.3 171 197 4.4 160 3.6 81.9 Ken Anderson Rushing 2-4 Career postseason G Att Yards Avg TD 192 397 2220 5.6 20 Something I take note of out of these stats...McNabb has more TD's...and almost half as many INT's.
January 14, 200917 yr These 2 are very comparable. McNabb - Passing 10 year Career 5 time pro-Bowler; 9-5 career Postseason G ATT Com Com% A/G Y Avg Y/G TD TD% Int Int% Rate 134 4,303 2,534 58.9 32.1 29,320 6.8 218.8 194 4.5 90 2.1 85.9 McNabb - Rushing G A Y Avg TD 134 536 3,109 5.8 26 Ken Anderson - Passing 4 time Pro-Bowl, 1 time 1st team All-Pro; 4 time passing leader G Att Com Comp% Att/Game Y AVG Y/G TD TD % INT INT% Rate 192 4475 2654 59.3 23.3 32,838 7.3 171 197 4.4 160 3.6 81.9 Ken Anderson Rushing 2-4 Career postseason G Att Yards Avg TD 192 397 2220 5.6 20 Never in a million years would I have guessed Anderson had 20 rushing TD's and over 2000 yards rushing!!
January 19, 200917 yr I'm sorry, but if Jim Kelly and Fran Tarkenton are HOFers, McNabb is. I totally agree with this statement.:thumb:
January 19, 200917 yr I'm sorry, but if Jim Kelly and Fran Tarkenton are HOFers, McNabb is. Im not a McNabb fan but you make a great point for him here.
January 19, 200917 yr I'm sorry, but if Jim Kelly and Fran Tarkenton are HOFers, McNabb is. Yeah, but those guys got to the superbowl 4 times and 3 times respectively. McNabb needs to lose at least two more to be in the same conversation.
January 19, 200917 yr He has had very little around him his whole career. I wish he would get traded somewhere he is appreciated and Philly would be terrible for a long time!
January 19, 200917 yr I'm sorry, but if Jim Kelly and Fran Tarkenton are HOFers, McNabb is. Isn't Tarkenton in or near the top 5 in nearly every statistical category?
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.