January 19, 200917 yr Author Isn't Tarkenton in or near the top 5 in nearly every statistical category? Certainly in those where longevity is a factor (yards, TDs, wins, etc.). For QB efficiency rating, we have: #14 - Donovan McNabb #20 - Jim Kelly #42 - Fran Tarkenton Not that QB rating should be the be-all, end-all HOF determinant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_career_quarterback_rating_leaders
January 19, 200917 yr Isn't Tarkenton in or near the top 5 in nearly every statistical category? Donovan is a top-notch winner. It would be a shame if he is denied the HOF for nit-picky reasons. Don't vote against him just because he plays against your favorite team. That would be like me saying Ray Lewis isn't HOF-caliber.
January 19, 200917 yr Donovan is a top-notch winner. It would be a shame if he is denied the HOF for nit-picky reasons. Don't vote against him just because he plays against your favorite team. That would be like me saying Ray Lewis isn't HOF-caliber. But Ray Lewis has something McNabb doesn't. A ring. McNabb is a top notch winner until it comes to the NFC Championship. And then he chokes. BTW, I don't get a vote.
January 19, 200917 yr But Ray Lewis has something McNabb doesn't. A ring. McNabb is a top notch winner until it comes to the NFC Championship. And then he chokes. BTW, I don't get a vote. So boot Marino out. It's a garbage threshold. McNabb's done all he can with the crummy cast he's been dealt with. It's a slam-dunk, as far as I'm concerned. And you're still not being objective about it.
January 19, 200917 yr So boot Marino out. It's a garbage threshold. McNabb's done all he can with the crummy cast he's been dealt with. It's a slam-dunk, as far as I'm concerned. And you're still not being objective about it. :thumb: I don't know if he's a HOFer or not, I really don't pay enough attention to that sort of thing to make an intelligent argument one way or another, but the SB requirement is ridiculous.
January 19, 200917 yr So boot Marino out. It's a garbage threshold. McNabb's done all he can with the crummy cast he's been dealt with. It's a slam-dunk, as far as I'm concerned. And you're still not being objective about it. Are McNabb's numbers as good as Marino's?
January 19, 200917 yr So boot Marino out. It's a garbage threshold. McNabb's done all he can with the crummy cast he's been dealt with. It's a slam-dunk, as far as I'm concerned. And you're still not being objective about it. It is of my opinion that he doesn't deserve to be in right now. If he continues to produce and move up the ranks in stats, I'd say he should be considered. As of now, I just don't think he's hall of fame worthy.
January 19, 200917 yr I didn't realize that Chris Carter was eligible and not voted in. How can the 2nd most prolific pass catcher in NFL history not be a 1st ballot Hall of Famer??? Dick LeBeau is in the top 10 in career INTs and he didn't get in. I don't get the whole voting system.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.