I know Manning won it but who do you think deserved it ?

Rhodes...

 

From the beginning, I thought it was going to be Addai but in the 2nd half the game was more in Rhodes' hands.. He had over 100 yards and a TD... Kept a few key posessions alive for the Colts.

 

Peyton had an alright game, but only won MVP because he's Peyton IMO.

Rhodes

21 carries

113 yards

1 TD

 

Addai

19 carries

77 yards rushing

10 catches

66 yards recieving

 

Manning

25 of 38

247 yards

1 TD 1 INT

I would have gave it to one of the runningbacks or Bob Sanders..But Manning also played a good enough game to win it as well though!

Bob Sanders, no question in my book.

Bob Sanders, no question in my book.

I agree... It's hard to believe he's only 5'8"..

I thought that Rex Grossman did one heck of a job in helping the Colts win last night :eek: . He should had definately got some votes.

None of the above. I thought the play of the game was the interception return for TD made by Haynes, and that with the solid but unspectacular play of everyone else, this would have been good enough to get MVP.

Joseph Addai

19 carries

77 yards rushing

10 catches

66 yards recieving

Rhodes...

 

From the beginning, I thought it was going to be Addai but in the 2nd half the game was more in Rhodes' hands.. He had over 100 yards and a TD... Kept a few key posessions alive for the Colts.

 

Peyton had an alright game, but only won MVP because he's Peyton IMO.

 

That was Rhodes' first 100+ game of the year. He made it tough to stop the run and opened up the field a lot. You have to give it to him.

Rhodes

Rhodes...

 

From the beginning, I thought it was going to be Addai but in the 2nd half the game was more in Rhodes' hands.. He had over 100 yards and a TD... Kept a few key posessions alive for the Colts.

 

Peyton had an alright game, but only won MVP because he's Peyton IMO.

 

My thoughts as well. Peyton would have won it if he'd only had 100 yards passing.

Rhodes!!!!!!!!

My thoughts as well. Peyton would have won it if he'd only had 100 yards passing.

:thumb: :thumb:

The pass opened the running game up. The defense was so worried about getting burned downfield they gave up the short pass the entire game and allowed Indy to run it down their throats. The safetys were lined up 20+ yards downfield. Chicago stayed in that weak zone the entire game waiting for Manning to make a mistake. The only mistake he made was basically a 30 yard punt that Devin Hester couldn't return on 3rd and 12. They also blitzed that play. Manning totally dictated the pace of the game. He opened up the run and threw the ball very well. (I remember 3 drops off the top of my head, 2 passes that the reciever touched, then was hit and dropped it, and the INT which didn't matter anyway.) Without Manning at the helm the Colts wouldn't have been as good. When 2 RB's go crazy they split the MVP vote and defensively nobody stood out enough to beat 25-38 247 yards.