Brady or Dalton?

[Clyde]

Hold on. Not today.

 

Brady is 38.

 

Which QB would you take if you had to base it on the next 5 seasons?

[NKY Bandit]

Brady. All day. Everyday.

 

NOOOO Doubt about it.

[Clyde]

Brady. All day. Everyday. NOOOO Doubt about it.

 

Even at age 43?

[75center]

Brady. I'll take my chances. Dalton has to sustain his current level longer and win some big games for me to buy in and the way Brady is playing even in 5 years at 43 he'll be top notch. Unless of course he goes south in a hurry like Manning.

[TheDeuce]

Brady with zero hesitation.

[MJAlltheWay24]

I'll go ahead and buy in on Dalton. I get him for five years and if he's still playing at a high level, I'll probably be able to resign him again for a few more years if I'd like.

[Getslow]

Sometimes those years start to catch up to you. Raise your hand if you've felt those effects of aging recently...

 

[Bengal Maniac]

I'd take Brady because the team would likely be in the Super Bowl with him in the next three years, even if the last two are not good.

 

AD will be a very good QB for a while, but Brady is the best I have ever seen. I think this is a no-brainer. To be fair over the next 5 years Rodgers would be the ONLY one that I'd consider over Brady.

[cathbird]

I can guarantee that Brady will win at least one super bowl in the next 5 years, and maybe 2. I can't say that for Dalton.

[Wireman]

I would take Brady at age 50 over Dalton. Brady all day. 100%

[UKMustangFan]

Brady and it's not even a question.

[TheDeuce]

Unless Dalton's offensive line is significantly better than Brady's, I don't see how this would be much of a discussion.

[I gotta go to work]

I'll bite.

Dalton.

Younger, more weapons, better run game.

[hidinout]

Maybe when Tom is 65 they equal out .

[se7ens]

Is Peyton's decline more about the natural effects of aging or the fact is neck is completely shot?

 

Also, can you name the oldest QB ever to start an NFL game?