October 30, 201510 yr Hold on. Not today. Brady is 38. Which QB would you take if you had to base it on the next 5 seasons?
October 30, 201510 yr Brady. I'll take my chances. Dalton has to sustain his current level longer and win some big games for me to buy in and the way Brady is playing even in 5 years at 43 he'll be top notch. Unless of course he goes south in a hurry like Manning.
October 30, 201510 yr I'll go ahead and buy in on Dalton. I get him for five years and if he's still playing at a high level, I'll probably be able to resign him again for a few more years if I'd like.
October 30, 201510 yr Sometimes those years start to catch up to you. Raise your hand if you've felt those effects of aging recently...
October 30, 201510 yr I'd take Brady because the team would likely be in the Super Bowl with him in the next three years, even if the last two are not good. AD will be a very good QB for a while, but Brady is the best I have ever seen. I think this is a no-brainer. To be fair over the next 5 years Rodgers would be the ONLY one that I'd consider over Brady.
October 30, 201510 yr I can guarantee that Brady will win at least one super bowl in the next 5 years, and maybe 2. I can't say that for Dalton.
October 30, 201510 yr Unless Dalton's offensive line is significantly better than Brady's, I don't see how this would be much of a discussion.
October 30, 201510 yr Is Peyton's decline more about the natural effects of aging or the fact is neck is completely shot? Also, can you name the oldest QB ever to start an NFL game?
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.