January 6, 201412 yr 1 though 32 for NFL starting QBs where do you rate him? For reference from NFL.com near the start of the season: 1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers 2. Tom Brady, New England Patriots 3. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos 4. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints 5. Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers 6. Andrew Luck, Indianapolis Colts 7. Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons 8. Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks 9. Colin Kaepernick, San Francisco 49ers 10. Joe Flacco, Baltimore Ravens 11. Robert Griffin III, Washington Redskins 12. Eli Manning, New York Giants 13. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys 14. Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers 15. Jay Cutler, Chicago Bears 16. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions 17. Matt Schaub, Houston Texans 18. Ryan Tannehill, Miami Dolphins 19. Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers 20. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles 21. Sam Bradford, St. Louis Rams 22. Carson Palmer, Arizona Cardinals 23. Andy Dalton, Cincinnati Bengals 24. Josh Freeman, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 25. Alex Smith, Kansas City Chiefs 26. EJ Manuel, Buffalo Bills 27. Jake Locker, Tennessee Titans 28. Brandon Weeden, Cleveland Browns 29. Christian Ponder, Minnesota Vikings 30. Geno Smith, New York Jets 31. Terrelle Pryor, Oakland Raiders 32. Blaine Gabbert, Jacksonville Jaguars
January 6, 201412 yr No way you have RGIII above Dalton today. I would put Smith ahead of Dalton. I'd take Dalton over Schaub. Newton is a TBD. They don't put the game in his hands yet. He may get there but not yet.
January 6, 201412 yr Dalton finished 15th in the NFL QB ratings, right behind Alex Smith and just ahead of Cam Newton. (passers with 200+ attempts) NFL Stats: by Player Position Dalton has lowest QB rating in the playoff games so far. Also, please note Dalton tied for 1st in the NFL in passes completed of 40 yards or more. He was 6th in completions of 20 yards or more. He was 3rd in TD passes and 6th in INT's.
January 6, 201412 yr Author No way you have RGIII above Dalton today. I would put Smith ahead of Dalton. I'd take Dalton over Schaub. Newton is a TBD. They don't put the game in his hands yet. He may get there but not yet. I will take RG3 and Cam right now over Dalton every day of the week.
January 6, 201412 yr No way you have RGIII above Dalton today. I would put Smith ahead of Dalton. I'd take Dalton over Schaub. Newton is a TBD. They don't put the game in his hands yet. He may get there but not yet. Agree with all of that, with the exception of Newton. He brings a dimension Dalton doesn't. And I'm not fond of Dalton when you put the game in his hands either.
January 6, 201412 yr Author Agree with all of that, with the exception of Newton. He brings a dimension Dalton doesn't. And I'm not fond of Dalton when you put the game in his hands either. So if Washington called the Bengals today and wanted to trade RG3 straight up for Andy Dalton you would say no? And assume you are a Bengals fan and have their best interests in mind.
January 6, 201412 yr So if Washington called the Bengals today and wanted to trade RG3 straight up for Andy Dalton you would say no? And assume you are a Bengals fan and have their best interests in mind. Cam, definitely yes. RG3, I think, is damaged goods, based on his Washington experience.
January 6, 201412 yr I will take RG3 and Cam right now over Dalton every day of the week. You can have RG3. What have you seen from Cam?
January 6, 201412 yr 7 of the 8 QBs playing next weekend are ranked in the top 14. And I'd say Rivers may be a little low at 19. Looks like you do need a good QB to succeed in the NFL
January 6, 201412 yr I'd probably put him somewhere in that 15-17 range. I'd move Flacco back to around 15, and move Stafford, Smith and Rivers Higher. up higher. Vick and Schaub shouldn't be on the list, so really, 17 is probably a good spot. Just a touch below average.
January 6, 201412 yr 7 of the 8 QBs playing next weekend are ranked in the top 14. And I'd say Rivers may be a little low at 19. Looks like you do need a good QB to succeed in the NFL That is Mike Brown rule #1. You probably don't want to hear that but it is true.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.