someone posted this question in the coach of the year thread. how about we make a new thread

Trinity vs the Kentucky All-State team

Unless you're saying the All-State team gets 30+ days to practice then it's T.

And if the All State team gets 30+ days to practice, it no doubt is the All State team and it isn't close.

And if the All State team gets 30+ days to practice, it no doubt is the All State team and it isn't close.

an all state time would close the gap with Trinity but 30 days is not enough being this Trinity squad has been together far beyond just this season. Both thier offense/defense is schemed to near profections. This alone would give The Rocks the advanage on an all state time.

I'm not going to put a number value on how long the team should practice, but simply assume that the all-state team would operate like a team. In that case, I certainly think they would win. If you just threw them together and played a game, it doesn't seem as likely, IMO.

Most any year the easy answer would be the All Stars but this was a special season and my money would be on the Rocks. Assuming Trinity gets to keep their coaches and not have a Coverdale utilizing the talent on the All Star Team.

The All State Team. Trinity could make a game of it, but the All State Team wouldn't have any weaknesses where most high school football teams have 2-3 players that are role players at best

The All State Team. Trinity could make a game of it, but the All State Team wouldn't have any weaknesses where most high school football teams have 2-3 players that are role players at best

but that's not the case with this Trinity squad they have no weakness as stated by several of the opposing Coaches.

Sort of surprised this thread title is not THS vs. LSU, who wins? Could have at least gone for a National HS All-Star team. :idunno:

Sort of surprised this thread title is not THS vs. LSU, who wins? Could have at least gone for a National HS All-Star team. :idunno:

 

Could not agree more!

 

Nice season. You won 6A. You had the best team in the state this year. You were national champs in some polls. 30 days practice w/ any of the other state championship coaches and the all state team wins by 40. Yes I said Trinity gets beat by 40. Again, nice season. Great team. You do not have the best player in the state at most positions. In your proposed matchup you have an advantage over the opponent in about two or three positions on each side of the ball. on the other 8 or 9 matchups you are disadvantaged and in some cases by a large margin.

I hope your not offended by the reality of your silly question, and I will try to not be offended by the question itself.

Could not agree more!

 

Nice season. You won 6A. You had the best team in the state this year. You were national champs in some polls. 30 days practice w/ any of the other state championship coaches and the all state team wins by 40. Yes I said Trinity gets beat by 40. Again, nice season. Great team. You do not have the best player in the state at most positions. In your proposed matchup you have an advantage over the opponent in about two or three positions on each side of the ball. on the other 8 or 9 matchups you are disadvantaged and in some cases by a large margin.

I hope your not offended by the reality of your silly question, and I will try to not be offended by the question itself.

With all due respect I played D1 ball and I say this to state that Trinity has D1 players at just about every position and the ones who are not are pretty close. as far as an allstar team based off the AP most of those guys are not D1. I say this not to disrespect those kids only to show, you under estimate just how good this Trinity Squad is. See is believing!

I lean more towards ColdHard's prediction than any prediction that Trinity would win.

Well how about I say this another way. If a Kentucky allstar team (minus the Trinity players) were to play Don Boscoe. Don Boscoe would win for the the same reason I stated before. Also in most years even with Trinity players. A Kentucky allstar team would not be the the #1 team in the nation. Also how many #1 teams in the nation that didn't D1 players at just about every position. just go back and look.

Well how about I say this another way. If a Kentucky allstar team (minus the Trinity players) were to play Don Boscoe. Don Boscoe would win for the the same reason I stated before. Also in most years even with Trinity players. A Kentucky allstar team would not be the the #1 team in the nation. Also how many #1 teams in the nation that didn't D1 players at just about every position. just go back and look.

So your saying that Trinity has almost 22 divison I players?