Would he go down in history as a better college player than Tim Tebow?

 

Thoughts?

Nope.

No.

Not even close IMO...

Why not?

 

Heismans would be 1-1

Titles would be 2-1 Tebow... even though he didn't start his freshman year.

McCoy holds the all-time record for most wins as a QB.

 

I don't know if he would, but I definitely think Colt would have an argument.

For those you who say no, would you like to explain why? I mean if that happens that means as a Starter Tebow would have been 1 and 2 in bowl games. Which if a player is suppose to be one of the best players in history, going 1 and 2 as a starter in the biggest games he plays in is not the best. While McCoy would have a heisman too, and a title as a starter just like Tebow. Who knows if it wasn't for Texas getting robbed last year, McCoy might already have a title and Tebow with none as a starter.

No, Tim has set records that probaby last a long time. Tougher conference, size, able to beat you in so many ways, leader.

 

I like Colt and if he wins the award I wouldn't be surprised. Hope he finds a good fit in the NFL.

No, Tim has set records that probaby last a long time. Tougher conference, size, able to beat you in so many ways, leader.

 

I like Colt and if he wins the award I wouldn't be surprised. Hope he finds a good fit in the NFL.

 

Colt has set records.

Colt can beat you in many ways.

Colt is a leader.

I think accomplishment wise he would have to be in consideration. As a player, I say no way. Colt McCoy is very good, but Tebow just seems great even in his bad game to me. JMO.

Tim has set TD records since 1980.

 

Colt won't win Heisman, Tim will

 

Tim is a better leader.

 

Save this thread if Gators play the Horns.

 

Gators play Bama

 

Horns play Huskers.

 

They asked for reasons, and I obeyed.

Probably not but it would defintley take away Tebow from being considered the best ever since they were in the same class.

For those you who say no, would you like to explain why? I mean if that happens that means as a Starter Tebow would have been 1 and 2 in bowl games. Which if a player is suppose to be one of the best players in history, going 1 and 2 as a starter in the biggest games he plays in is not the best. While McCoy would have a heisman too, and a title as a starter just like Tebow. Who knows if it wasn't for Texas getting robbed last year, McCoy might already have a title and Tebow with none as a starter.

 

:thumb:

This is the same type scenario as the question "is Pryor as good as Tebow" the stats say so. But he's not even close!

Nope. Don't have to give a reason. It's an opinion.

This is the same type scenario as the question "is Pryor as good as Tebow" the stats say so. But he's not even close!

 

Not a good analogy at all.