If Colt McCoy were to win the Heisman and National Championship...

[Original Rookie]

Would he go down in history as a better college player than Tim Tebow?

 

Thoughts?

[bigblueinsanity]

Nope.

[FairFan]

No.

[UKMustangFan]

Not even close IMO...

[Original Rookie]

Why not?

 

Heismans would be 1-1

Titles would be 2-1 Tebow... even though he didn't start his freshman year.

McCoy holds the all-time record for most wins as a QB.

 

I don't know if he would, but I definitely think Colt would have an argument.

[futurecoach]

For those you who say no, would you like to explain why? I mean if that happens that means as a Starter Tebow would have been 1 and 2 in bowl games. Which if a player is suppose to be one of the best players in history, going 1 and 2 as a starter in the biggest games he plays in is not the best. While McCoy would have a heisman too, and a title as a starter just like Tebow. Who knows if it wasn't for Texas getting robbed last year, McCoy might already have a title and Tebow with none as a starter.

[Alabama Larry]

No, Tim has set records that probaby last a long time. Tougher conference, size, able to beat you in so many ways, leader.

 

I like Colt and if he wins the award I wouldn't be surprised. Hope he finds a good fit in the NFL.

[Original Rookie]

No, Tim has set records that probaby last a long time. Tougher conference, size, able to beat you in so many ways, leader.

 

I like Colt and if he wins the award I wouldn't be surprised. Hope he finds a good fit in the NFL.

 

Colt has set records.

Colt can beat you in many ways.

Colt is a leader.

[CatsCatsCats]

I think accomplishment wise he would have to be in consideration. As a player, I say no way. Colt McCoy is very good, but Tebow just seems great even in his bad game to me. JMO.

[Alabama Larry]

Tim has set TD records since 1980.

 

Colt won't win Heisman, Tim will

 

Tim is a better leader.

 

Save this thread if Gators play the Horns.

 

Gators play Bama

 

Horns play Huskers.

 

They asked for reasons, and I obeyed.

[D IT UP]

Probably not but it would defintley take away Tebow from being considered the best ever since they were in the same class.

[KYHOOP]

For those you who say no, would you like to explain why? I mean if that happens that means as a Starter Tebow would have been 1 and 2 in bowl games. Which if a player is suppose to be one of the best players in history, going 1 and 2 as a starter in the biggest games he plays in is not the best. While McCoy would have a heisman too, and a title as a starter just like Tebow. Who knows if it wasn't for Texas getting robbed last year, McCoy might already have a title and Tebow with none as a starter.

 

:thumb:

[Ram Fan04]

This is the same type scenario as the question "is Pryor as good as Tebow" the stats say so. But he's not even close!

[swamprat]

Nope. Don't have to give a reason. It's an opinion.

[Original Rookie]

This is the same type scenario as the question "is Pryor as good as Tebow" the stats say so. But he's not even close!

 

Not a good analogy at all.