November 12, 200619 yr Should there be one? Andre' has been very impressive this year. What do you all think?
November 12, 200619 yr Should there be one? Andre' has been very impressive this year. What do you all think? 2006 Stats for Both Brohm 7 Games 93.9 QB Rating 115/189 Completions 60.8 Completion % 1786 Yards Passing 9.4 Yards Per Throw 255.1 Yards Per Game 6 TD/4 INT 28 Rushes/64 Yards 9.1 Yards Rushing Per Game/0 TD Sacked 13 Times Missed 2 Games This Season Teams Record - 8-1 Woodson 9 Games 143.5 QB Rating 164/275 Completions 59.6 Completion % 2125 Yards Passing 7.7 Yards Per Throw 236.1 Yards Per Game 48 Rushes/-84 Yards 20 TD/7 INT Sacked 24 Times Teams Record 6-4
November 12, 200619 yr 2006 Stats for Both Brohm 7 Games 93.9 QB Rating 115/189 Completions 60.8 Completion % 1786 Yards Passing 9.4 Yards Per Throw 255.1 Yards Per Game 6 TD/4 INT 28 Rushes/64 Yards 9.1 Yards Rushing Per Game/0 TD Sacked 13 Times Missed 2 Games This Season Teams Record - 8-1 Woodson 9 Games 143.5 QB Rating 164/275 Completions 59.6 Completion % 2125 Yards Passing 7.7 Yards Per Throw 236.1 Yards Per Game 48 Rushes/-84 Yards 20 TD/7 INT Sacked 24 Times Teams Record 6-4 You've got the team record for 10 games but his stats for only 9 games. You would have to add another 400+ passing yards and 4 touchdowns to those totals.
November 12, 200619 yr You've got the team record for 10 games but his stats for only 9 games. You would have to add another 400+ passing yards and 4 touchdowns to those totals. I guess you are right. Does he really have 739+ more yards than Brohm? Granted Brohm did not play in 2 games this season. Make that 24 TD's to Brohms 6!
November 12, 200619 yr Both are great QB's, Brohm has had to step up more this year with the loss of Bush.
November 12, 200619 yr Are you serious? Brohm hands down. Brohm is way better...better on long balls...better on touch passes...has a better feel in pocket...and is better in reading defenses. Andre has improved and will be much better next year...but the comparison is silly.
November 12, 200619 yr Are you serious? Brohm hands down. Brohm is way better...better on long balls...better on touch passes...has a better feel in pocket...and is better in reading defenses. Andre has improved and will be much better next year...but the comparison is silly. I disagree with you after watching him play against Rutgers this week. He wasn't comfortable in the pocket at all even when they were bringing 4 man pressures and had 5 to block it he was looking to tuck it. Brohm also has more talent around him. Better offensive line helps a LOT! I think Brohm is a very good player but I think Woodson is just as good if not better.
November 12, 200619 yr In my mind to trully compare them how would they be if they switched teams? One playing behind the others line and with their recievers. Would UK be better with Brohm at QB ,and would UL be better with Woodson?
November 12, 200619 yr I disagree with you after watching him play against Rutgers this week. He wasn't comfortable in the pocket at all even when they were bringing 4 man pressures and had 5 to block it he was looking to tuck it. Brohm also has more talent around him. Better offensive line helps a LOT! I think Brohm is a very good player but I think Woodson is just as good if not better. Whoa... Talkin bout sticking you neck out there... UL fan will come after you for that... although you have vaild points.
November 12, 200619 yr Are you serious? Brohm hands down. Brohm is way better...better on long balls...better on touch passes...has a better feel in pocket...and is better in reading defenses. Andre has improved and will be much better next year...but the comparison is silly. Thats awful brave to throw that out after how uncomposed he has looked this year. As for Arm comparisons....not sure you're right on those......you may need to watch the way Woodson throws the ball.
November 12, 200619 yr Nothing brave about it. Look Andre has made a great improvement. Yesterday, he had 3-4 open receivers for TD's and flat missed them. Andre is not very mobile and still takes unnecesary sacks...he is getting better and has done it behind a line that is average. Brohm is a first round pick...he can change so many things at the LOS. He is fairly accurate. Woodson has had games where he was taken to the shed...see LSU.
November 12, 200619 yr Nothing brave about it. Look Andre has made a great improvement. Yesterday, he had 3-4 open receivers for TD's and flat missed them. Andre is not very mobile and still takes unnecesary sacks...he is getting better and has done it behind a line that is average. Brohm is a first round pick...he can change so many things at the LOS. He is fairly accurate. Woodson has had games where he was taken to the shed...see LSU. Yeah Brohm is a first round pick based on name and school. Woodson though may have the better NFL career. You're saying that Brohm didn't miss any recievers, they have about the same complation %.........didn't take any sacks. Thursday he looked like a deer in the headlights in the second half. Neither one has even good mobility.
November 12, 200619 yr Both are good QB's and do many things well. I would give the nod to Brohm right now. He makes better decisions and I think understands the game better than Woodson.Brohm is like a coach on the field.He reminds me of Peyton Manning in the way he controls the game. Woodson is vastly improved and is having a good year. He is still learning how to play QB and will only get better. He has the arm strength and the size to be a great QB if he continues to work. I also like that both of these young men have great character. I enjoy watching them both.
November 12, 200619 yr Both are good QB's and do many things well. I would give the nod to Brohm right now. He makes better decisions and I think understands the game better than Woodson.Brohm is like a coach on the field.He reminds me of Peyton Manning in the way he controls the game. Woodson is vastly improved and is having a good year. He is still learning how to play QB and will only get better. He has the arm strength and the size to be a great QB if he continues to work. I also like that both of these young men have great character. I enjoy watching them both. Whoa whoa whoa... Payton Manning....I dont kno about that one...:creepy:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.