December 12, 20169 yr Bell is playing with a top 3 QB, top 3 WR, and top five o-line. Elliott only has a top 3 o-line. Dak has been very good and Dez might be the 5th best WR. My point is Bell has lots of help, also. He ain't doing it alone. He is not AP doing it alone good. Right now he is playing great. Big Ben a top 3 QB???
December 12, 20169 yr Author McCoy is better than Murray. We have discussed the top 2. A healthy AP is better than all of them. Shame he isn't healthy, so he can't be on the list. AP didn't do anything before he got hurt.
December 12, 20169 yr Brady is only better. Maybe Rodgers or Brees. Total Qbr rating for 2016--- Dak Prescott=#1 Ben Rothlisberger=#12 NFL Total Quarterback Rating - National Football League - ESPN
December 12, 20169 yr Total Qbr rating for 2016--- Dak Prescott=#1 Ben Rothlisberger=#12 NFL Total Quarterback Rating - National Football League - ESPN You want Dak or Ben under center in a one game scenario?
December 12, 20169 yr You want Dak or Ben under center in a one game scenario? Brady:lol2: Kidding. Out of the two I'm taking Ben
December 12, 20169 yr I'd take Bell if he can stay available for every contest I would definitely take Bell over Elliott.
December 12, 20169 yr Big Ben a top 3 QB??? My thoughts exactly. Big Ben is definitely good, but give Drew Brees the weapons he has and see what he does, as an example.
December 12, 20169 yr You want Dak or Ben under center in a one game scenario? Of course I'd take Ben. My only point is that statistically, Prescott is having the better year, and the argument that Bell has less to do isn't necessarily valid, at least at the QB position.
December 12, 20169 yr Guys, I totally respect Brady and Ben and how terrific Dak has been. Brees is awesome. But the most skilled signal caller is that Packers QB. I don't think it's close
December 12, 20169 yr Guys, I totally respect Brady and Ben and how terrific Dak has been. Brees is awesome. But the most skilled signal caller is that Packers QB. I don't think it's close Agreed. TB12 is the GOAT, but Rodgers is clearly, IMO, the best in the league currently.
December 12, 20169 yr My thoughts exactly. Big Ben is definitely good, but give Drew Brees the weapons he has and see what he does, as an example. Brees is great, however the system he plays in also helps. Not to mention he is guaranteed almost every year to play about at least 14 games a year in almost perfect conditions. 8 games in a dome at home, and then other teams in the south. While Brees is great, I doubt he would have been as great playing in the AFC north division his whole career.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.