July 9, 201511 yr Author No way Reggie Sanders makes this list over the Cobra. Maybe they meant Deion
July 9, 201511 yr Guys that I remember playing that were nice players but probably wouldn't make anyone's list and for good reason. There are great players at every position. This list are just some guys that popped in my head, some only played one season with the Reds but were productive and others played multiple seasons with the Reds and were productive for one or more but not for there entire career. Edwin for example showed flashes of being exactly what he has become in TOR and would've easily been in discussion for best 3B in Reds History at least offensively (defensive train wreck) had he not been traded or changed positions. Benito Santiago-Catcher Dmitri Young-1B/OF Todd Walker-2B D'Angelo Jimenez-2B Edwin Encarnacion-3B Felipe Lopez-SS Mike Cameron-OF Greg Vaughn-OF Daunte Bichette-OF Deion Sanders-OF Willy Mo Pena-OF
July 9, 201511 yr We've had several threads about All-Time Reds teams and they are always and rightfully so, dominated by players from the Big Red Machine. So name your All-Time Reds lineup without any players that played for Cincy from 1970-1976 Here is mine off of the top of my head...I'm only going with players since the BRM, ones I've actually watched. 1B Votto 2B Phillips 3B Frazier SS Larkin LF E Davis CF Griffey Jr RF Parker C Oliver SP Rijo RP Chapman Frank Robinson, Big Klu,?????
July 9, 201511 yr No way Reggie Sanders makes this list over the Cobra. I thought the stipulation was that you've seen them play. How are we supposed to include Parker if he was before our time?
July 9, 201511 yr Author Frank Robinson, Big Klu,????? I just went with players that I've seen, which would be none before the BRM.
July 18, 201511 yr I just went with players that I've seen, which would be none before the BRM. Then that wouldn't be "all time "
July 18, 201511 yr Author Then that wouldn't be "all time " That was my personal picks, older guys are available to everyone to choose
July 18, 201511 yr 1B: Klu 2B: BP SS: Larkin 3B: Sabo C: Lombardi LF: Dunn CF: Davis RF: Robinson Nice! Although I would swap out Dunn for Vada Pinson.
July 20, 201511 yr Nobody picking the Nasty Boys? IMO I would take them over Chapman. Maybe not all three ahead of the Cuban Missile, but at least one or two.
July 20, 201511 yr The minute anyone listed anyone other than BP at 2B, this thread jumped the shark.
July 20, 201511 yr C Lombardi 1B Klu 2B McPhee SS Larkin 3B Groh OF Roush OF Robinson OF Pinson/Griffey SP: Soto, Maloney, Walters, Seaver, Rijo RP: Myers, Graves
July 20, 201511 yr Author The minute anyone listed anyone other than BP at 2B, this thread jumped the shark. C Lombardi 1B Klu 2B McPhee SS Larkin 3B Groh OF Roush OF Robinson OF Pinson/Griffey SP: Soto, Maloney, Walters, Seaver, Rijo RP: Myers, Graves
July 20, 201511 yr Was Vada Pinson a Gold Glove outfielder? Did he play mostly CF? I'm not sure why some of these guys are getting picked over Dunn.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.