May 5, 201214 yr Author I think what killed Skylar was her second performance. There was something about it that just turned me off. Maybe she was trying too hard, but she seemed to be struggling and it didn't come off well. Using Jennifer's words, Skylar is a "stay in your lane" performer. Amazing when she gives you what she knows. But she struggles to deliver anything else.
May 7, 201214 yr Hopefully the next to go will be the Dave Matthews impersonator! Phillip has the brightest future of any of the remaining 5.
May 10, 201214 yr Great night on AI. I was stunned by Josh Ledet's "Man's World." Blew me away. Joshua Ledet - It's A Mans World - American Idol 2012 (Top 4) - Video Dailymotion I'm still hoping for a Josh/Phillip final.
May 10, 201214 yr Author Great night on AI. I was stunned by Josh Ledet's "Man's World." Blew me away. Joshua Ledet - It's A Mans World - American Idol 2012 (Top 4) - Video Dailymotion I'm still hoping for a Josh/Phillip final. I think the judges do too. I also think that the judges were obvious on their choice for the final 3---and it does not include Holly.
May 10, 201214 yr I think the judges do too. I also think that the judges were obvious on their choice for the final 3---and it does not include Holly. Agreed. Good singer. Not nearly as good as the other 3. While I've always respected the Sanchez girl's talent she's often bored me. Last night she killed it on both songs.
May 10, 201214 yr I've watched AI for several years and I think this year's Final 4 is by for the worst.
May 10, 201214 yr I've watched AI for several years and I think this year's Final 4 is by for the worst. Stunning. Most , including me, think it's outstanding final 3 assuming the blonde girl goes. Just shows how we all have different tastes.
May 10, 201214 yr Stunning. Most , including me, think it's outstanding final 3 assuming the blonde girl goes. Just shows how we all have different tastes. I agree. Although I think Holly has every right to be there too.
May 10, 201214 yr I agree. Although I think Holly has every right to be there too. There as in "final 3?"
May 10, 201214 yr There as in "final 3?"No, I guess I mean just on a legitimate footing to be included among the final four. I think she and Phillip will probably go home over the next two shows -- in no particular order. If I would have my choice though, it would be Phillip and either Joshua or Holly in the final.
May 10, 201214 yr No, I guess I mean just on a legitimate footing to be included among the final four. I think she and Phillip will probably go home over the next two shows -- in no particular order. If I would have my choice though, it would be Phillip and either Joshua or Holly in the final. I agree. She went as far as she could. I think you'll see Josh v Phillip in the final.
May 10, 201214 yr I agree. She went as far as she could. I think you'll see Josh v Phillip in the final. Jessica's strong performance (especially in the last song) has me worried that she may send Phillip home.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.