That's the thing, I know I'm not wrong. It's not a personal battle either. I do have some strong opinions, but I cant get past the FACT that they were revealing a new member of the Oceanic 6 and we meet Aaron.

When was Jack revealed? If he wasnt, then Jack wasnt either.

I know how Lost works. I know things get crazy sometimes, but I just dont get where things arent clicking.

You mean when they revealed Hurley and he is one of the "6", you didnt automatically say Hurley, Jack, and Kate, after the end to season 3?

That's the thing, I know I'm not wrong. It's not a personal battle either. I do have some strong opinions, but I cant get past the FACT that they were revealing a new member of the Oceanic 6 and we meet Aaron.

When was Jack revealed? If he wasnt, then Jack wasnt either.

I know how Lost works. I know things get crazy sometimes, but I just dont get where things arent clicking.

You mean when they revealed Hurley and he is one of the "6", you didnt automatically say Hurley, Jack, and Kate, after the end to season 3?

 

Okay, you KNOW you are not wrong. You keep telling yourself that. :lol:

 

It's not about strong opinions...you try to make it seem like the only opinion that matters is yours. There is NO WAY POSSIBLE for you to KNOW you are right, unless you've read spoilers. Otherwise, please refrain from saying you KNOW anything because that is completely untrue.

No, I know I'm right. It's possible. Just ask me.

No, I know I'm right. It's possible. Just ask me.

 

Okay, you KNOW. Now I don't have to watch the next few episodes, because since you know all about Lost, you can just tell me what is going to happen. :lol:

 

We'll see who is right soon enough. It's going to be a great day when I'm right. :thumb:

You were right about something tonight, just not this.

 

How do you know you are so right if you havent read spoilers?

Also, don't forget that Benry could possibly be a member of the Oceanic 6. Everyone remember his room full of passports and such? And he first tricked the Oceanic survivors into thinking he was Henry gale...he's a master of disguise.

 

Not according to this week's show where he watched the plane go down with the rest of the people and then sent Juliet's adulterous lover into the group of Oceanic survivors.

I am loving this thread almost as much as I love the show!!!:lol:

Not according to this week's show where he watched the plane go down with the rest of the people and then sent Juliet's adulterous lover into the group of Oceanic survivors.

 

What?

 

I'm saying Ben could fake like he was on the plane...seeing as how he has all of the passports and is so good at acting like someone else. It's not likely, but its possible. The writers of the show have even mentioned not to count Ben out as a member of the Oceanic 6.

You were right about something tonight, just not this.

 

How do you know you are so right if you havent read spoilers?

 

I told you why I think Jin and Sun are the last two. The next episode is a Jin/Sun centric. The only episodes thus far that have involved original members of flight 815 have been flash forwards of members of the oceanic 6. That's why I think they are part of the oceanic 6. I stopped reading spoilers last year after I ruined last seasons finale. I was furious with myself and vowed to never read another spoiler.

What?

 

I'm saying Ben could fake like he was on the plane...seeing as how he has all of the passports and is so good at acting like someone else. It's not likely, but its possible. The writers of the show have even mentioned not to count Ben out as a member of the Oceanic 6.

 

On this week's show, Ben, Juliet, and the rest of the others were in the yard when the plane went down. They even had cool special effects watching the plane separate in the air and the two different parts fall to the ocean.

 

At that point, the guy Juliet was having an affair with (was the guy that was killed by someone in the first season up on top of a mountain) was told by Ben to go to where the wreckage was and infiltrate the survivors.

 

While he might have been named on the manifest, he most definitely wasn't on the plane.

I told you why I think Jin and Sun are the last two. The next episode is a Jin/Sun centric. The only episodes thus far that have involved original members of flight 815 have been flash forwards of members of the oceanic 6. That's why I think they are part of the oceanic 6. I stopped reading spoilers last year after I ruined last seasons finale. I was furious with myself and vowed to never read another spoiler.

 

I could see one but not both.

On this week's show, Ben, Juliet, and the rest of the others were in the yard when the plane went down. They even had cool special effects watching the plane separate in the air and the two different parts fall to the ocean.

 

At that point, the guy Juliet was having an affair with (was the guy that was killed by someone in the first season up on top of a mountain) was told by Ben to go to where the wreckage was and infiltrate the survivors.

 

While he might have been named on the manifest, he most definitely wasn't on the plane.

 

I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I'm not implying that Ben was in fact on the plane. I am saying it would be entirely possible for Ben to make it LOOK like he was on the plane, so that he could be one of the Oceanic 6. I realize it's doubtful, but even the writers mentioned it so its possible.

 

They have shown the scene with Julet/Ben/Goodwin watching the plane crash before...that was not the first time that was shown.

I could see one but not both.

 

It's a Jin/Sun centric episode...it'll either be both or neither.

I could see one but not both.

 

It's a Jin/Sun centric episode...it'll either be both or neither.

 

It's hard to have an episode focus on just one of the two. Any episode with anything about one is going to have to focus on the other as well.

 

You think there is no chance that Sun has to go it alone? I thought I was hard headed...

It's hard to have an episode focus on just one of the two. Any episode with anything about one is going to have to focus on the other as well.

 

You think there is no chance that Sun has to go it alone? I thought I was hard headed...

 

The only way I see only Sun going is if Jin dies.

 

I don't think Jin or Sun would want to be separated..