August 11, 20188 yr Author McMurphy says the source is not Herman. Herman has come out and said the same. Curious how Jeff Snook responds to this. Before this post, anything Jeff Snook said has been followed by an edit from McMurphy on his original Facebook post.
August 11, 20188 yr Author Just as an aside before Herman’s name was mentioned it was rumored that Ed Warriner was the tipster. Which would make a hell of a lot more since than Herman considering Herman hadn’t even been around the program since early 2015.
August 11, 20188 yr I get that there may be this michevious Texas connection which led to all of the hoopla, but these are separate stories, aren’t they? This is like saying “you can’t tell the story of Christian Laettner without talking about Sean Woods.” Well, sure, but Laettner still happened. Intersting devlopment none-the-less. I’ll also admit I haven’t closely followed all of this.
August 11, 20188 yr I think self defense in a case of abuse is weak. I cannot think of any situation where it would be necessary for me to choke my wife or any other woman.
August 11, 20188 yr I think self defense in a case of abuse is weak. I cannot think of any situation where it would be necessary for me to choke my wife or any other woman. Incredibly weak.
August 11, 20188 yr I think self defense in a case of abuse is weak. I cannot think of any situation where it would be necessary for me to choke my wife or any other woman. Incredibly weak. Agreed. Choking is an act of aggression, not self defense. If Zach Smith choked his wife, IMO he is guilty of abuse.
August 11, 20188 yr Concerning the reporting, I believe reporters should have no obligation to protect the identity of a source if it is proven the source gave false information.
August 11, 20188 yr Agreed. Choking is an act of aggression, not self defense. If Zach Smith choked his wife, IMO he is guilty of abuse. Agree 100%.
August 11, 20188 yr McMurphy says he has texts from the victim's mom detailing Smith's repeated violence against her daughter.
August 11, 20188 yr What story would that be? The one where he admitted to choking her twice? That’s all the evidence I needed. Not sure why that gets over looked. What’s your thoughts on her mom taking ZS’s side? You keep trying to go off “text.” Do you have any idea how hard it is to admit text as evidence? Especially, when they aren’t corroborated by her carrier? We’re these text from her burner phone that she called BM on the first time, (he is on record saying) or her actual phone that she called him back on.
August 11, 20188 yr Basically her mom said that she believes anything Zach did was in self defense or trying to remove himself from the situation. Again I’m not proclaiming anything, but the fact that it’s HER mom saying this should at least make people think. McMurphy says he has texts from the victim's mom detailing Smith's repeated violence against her daughter. Why in the world would her mom exonerate Smith if she had proof of the violence? Something not adding up with conflicting stories about her mom.
August 11, 20188 yr McMurphy says he has texts from the victim's mom detailing Smith's repeated violence against her daughter. BM has edited his story multiple times now on FB, not once did he cite an edit which is journalism 101.
August 11, 20188 yr Why in the world would her mom exonerate Smith if she had proof of the violence? Something not adding up with conflicting stories about her mom. Where is the proof? Her mom is on record saying “she told me she was going to take down Smith and Urban Meyer.”
August 11, 20188 yr If it can be proven that Herman is the source which is TBD. I am a non-conformist, I only want facts. If it is proven... If ya’ll want to crucify Urban for lying at Big Ten media day have at it with Tom Herman who on 8/2 told the media he had no knowledge of any of the domestic disputes involving Zach and Courtney. That said, Herman should immediately be placed on leave if it’s proven.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.