Pumpkin Pie: Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down?

[Randy Parker]

I like a lot of things pumpkin, but Pumpkin Pie is not one of them. Thumbs Down for me.

 

What about you?

[TAC]

Once a year! That's it!

[Science Friction]

What in the hell is wrong with you Randy? You must have never tasted one of the really good ones.

 

Caveat: There are a lot of bad pumpkin pies out there. So, I'm talking about the good pumpkin pies. Big thumbs up!

[GrantNKY]

It's not my favorite but it's still a thumbs up for me. It's a solid 3rd on my list of favorite pies behind Apple and Pecan.

[bugatti]

I like a lot of things pumpkin, but Pumpkin Pie is not one of them. Thumbs Down for me.

 

What about you?

Get out of here.

 

Pumpkin pie is the bomb.

[Science Friction]

Was at the Golden Corral this weekend. Their pumpkin pie is not good. On the other hand, their pecan pie was quite tasty..

[Science Friction]

Get out of here.

 

Pumpkin pie is the bomb.

 

If it a good one, absolutely. There are some bad ones out there. Apparently, Randy has never tasted a good pumpkin pie.

[GrantNKY]

Was at the Golden Corral this weekend. Their pumpkin pie is not good. On the other hand, their pecan pie was quite tasty..

Golden Corral. :puke:

[Science Friction]

Golden Corral. :puke:

 

I know, I know. But they do have a few items that I am pretty fond of.

[lawildcat]

The only pie I like is chocolate creme.

[Getslow]

What in the hell is wrong with you Randy?

 

Whew. Big question.

 

My answer is in 27 parts and can be viewed as an attachment...

[rjs4470]

Two thumbs down. Pie should be made from fruit, not vegetables.

[GrantNKY]

Two thumbs down. Pie should be made from fruit, not vegetables.

Where does Pecan Pie fall into that equation?

[nees1212]

I try it every year, but I cannot get beyond one bite.

[rockmom]

Dammit! I agree with Randy again! 2 Thumbs down for me. Even the sight of it turnsy stomach.