Trade AJ McCarron and your first round pick to the Browns for the first pick of the draft?

I wouldn't if I were them.

 

They should still be able to get Derek Barnett with their 1st round pick and I don't think the difference between Garrett and Barnett is that large that you'd need to move McCarron. Now if they could do the #9 and McCarron for both Cleveland 1st rounders, I'd do it.

I wouldn't if I were them.

 

They should still be able to get Derek Barnett with their 1st round pick and I don't think the difference between Garrett and Barnett is that large that you'd need to move McCarron. Now if they could do the #9 and McCarron for both Cleveland 1st rounders, I'd do it.

Wonder how much say Hue has in that whole decision.

No. You basically are trading a guy to only move up 7 spots. I don't see that being that good of a deal for the bengals. Especially trading within the division.

I don't value AJ as much as others, but I also don't value the #1 pick as much as others. Like UKMF said, if you could trade AJ and get both of Cleveland's 1st round picks, I'd do that.

McCarron asked to be traded during the offseason.

I wouldn't make that trade either.

I would trade Marvin Lewis and Andy Dalton for a first round pick and a proven talent to replace Pacman Jones.

The Bengals need major help on the OLine and they need two more offensive weapons. Take either Green or Eiffert off the field, and Bengals offense was anemic. One player is not going to solve their problems. They need to draft for volume.

I'd do it. AJ I'm last year and will be gone next year. They are not losing any draft picks. Going from 9 to 1 is a HUGE leap up the board. The Browns won't do it. The Bengals would in a heart beat.

McCarron asked to be traded during the offseason.

 

Show me the quote where he is asking to be traded?

I would trade Marvin Lewis and Andy Dalton for a first round pick and a proven talent to replace Pacman Jones.

 

I'd also trade Brandon Phillips for Clayton Kershaw.

Browns won't trade both firsts. Maybe a 1st and a later pick.

 

Historically it is hard to get a higher pick for a guy then where he was drafted.

 

If Jackson really likes AJ, I would guess the absolute best trade the Bengals could get is the Browns extra 2nd round pick.

 

So Bengals 1st and AJ for Browns 1st and the extra 2nd.

 

 

As a Browns fan, I'm not sure I want to make that trade.

Show me the quote where he is asking to be traded?

Bengals QB AJ McCarron ready for offseason trade - NFL.com

It will be interesting to really see what value he has. I am not sure it is as high as some think. He has some good video out there, but he didn't knock your socks off, though. He does seem to have the "it" factor, that is not always enough, though. Timmy T had that, also.