They are fantastic!!! I look forward every year to when Brewster's has them, and then am bummed when they go away. I eat more milkshakes between Thanksgiving and February 1st than I eat the rest of the year. They are so freaking good!! :clap:

I don't care for peppermint, so thumbs down from me.

Always wanted to try one, but always end up getting mint chocolate chip instead. It's what I do.

I'm more of a chocolate, vanilla, fruity, or mocha freak. Though I like them, I'm not a big fan of either mint or peanut butter in my ice cream.

I've never had one and probably never will. Just doesn't sound appealing. I'm more of a straight up chocolate kind of girl.

Yuck

What mcpops said!

Never had one, but will try it next time I see it on a menu.

Thumbs down. Way down.

Not had one but Peppermint + Ice cream has to be yumsters!!! I know Steak N Shake has them. Peanut Butter is my numero uno shake.

Peanut Butter malt, made with chocolate milk. My favorite!!!!

Peppermint, not so much.....

They are fantastic!!! I look forward every year to when Brewster's has them, and then am bummed when they go away.

 

Is that place on 42? Close to Dunkin Donuts?

I don't like any milkshakes.

I don't like any milkshakes.

 

Oh my, hard to believe, almost unAmerican.:lol2:

Is that place on 42? Close to Dunkin Donuts?

 

Yeah, across the street from McDonalds and Taco Bell.

Things that's don't go together: chocolate and peppermint, Peppermint and ice cream. Big no thanks from me.