September 10, 201610 yr By rule, the last play should have never happened and Ok State should have won.
September 10, 201610 yr Author If they didn't keep it so close it may not have happened. I figured Oklahoma State would win more convincingly.
September 10, 201610 yr It's ridiculous that they won't just correct the screw up and declare Ok St the winner. Its embarrasing sing that they won't do that.
September 11, 201610 yr Okay, the rule is the rule. Black eye for the officials there. You can say the Ok. St. still had an opportunity to win it by stopping the hail Mary, but they shouldn't have been put in that situation. However, the rule, in my opinion, is ridiculously stupid to begin with. How in the world can you allow a team to intentionally commit a penalty, and not be penalized by it? I mean, isn't that the definition of penalty, that something "bad" happens to you as a result of your actions? How is it that you commit that same infraction anywhere else in the game, and there are consequences...but, hey do it at the end of the half or the end of the game, and not even a slap on the wrist?
September 11, 201610 yr Or if you have a holding call on an incomplete pass on 4th down its an untimed down. But a truly obvious infraction is rewarded by ending the game. Just make them all one in the same
September 11, 201610 yr I always say that officiating, no matter how bad hardy ever cost a team a win. This is one of those that it did. how those guys could have botched that last call / no call is beyond me.
September 11, 201610 yr Okay, the rule is the rule. Black eye for the officials there. You can say the Ok. St. still had an opportunity to win it by stopping the hail Mary, but they shouldn't have been put in that situation. However, the rule, in my opinion, is ridiculously stupid to begin with. How in the world can you allow a team to intentionally commit a penalty, and not be penalized by it? I mean, isn't that the definition of penalty, that something "bad" happens to you as a result of your actions? How is it that you commit that same infraction anywhere else in the game, and there are consequences...but, hey do it at the end of the half or the end of the game, and not even a slap on the wrist? This.
September 11, 201610 yr Just not sure how this was rationalized by the officials knowing the basics of football rules. - Grounding is a 'live ball' (during play) foul. - Thus, the foul was an 'offensive foul' while OKS had possession of the ball. - So you had an offensive, live ball foul as the last play. The 'general' rule is that a game or half can not end on a 'defensive' foul. But it was not, just a lost of down that would have resulted in the ball going over - had there been any time on the clock. But there was not and the game was over. It seems somehow this should have been caught. Its definitely not all on the white hat's head.
September 11, 201610 yr It's ridiculous that they won't just correct the screw up and declare Ok St the winner. Its embarrasing sing that they won't do that. Yep. And fire those MAC officials.
September 11, 201610 yr The MAC has suspended the officiating crew for two games. Big 12 suspends two-man replay crew two games as well.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.