Would you trade Stubbs and Chapman for Arod, Gardner, and Swisher?

 

I wouldn't give Chapman alone for those 3 plus Rivera and Jeter.

No.

 

I would never want my team to trade with the Yankees.

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd' date=' plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.[/quote']

 

This.

Edit...

 

Numbers were wrong.

This.

 

IF he goes anywhere, it will be to the Marlins, IMO.

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

And remember, 87 dingers at GASP. He can hit in the 4 hole since Votto will never go yard again.

And remember, 87 dingers at GASP. He can hit in the 4 hole since Votto will never go yard again.

 

With a number like that I would definitely take him.

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

 

Who you willing to give up in return?

88 mph fastball by him no thanks ill roll with Frazier for the term.

For little money I'd want the Reds to take a gamble, and this is from a guy that hates A-Rod as a player. I still think he would look good between Votto and Bruce.

Would have loved to have him 10 years ago at half the price.