Would you want your favorite team to trade for A-Rod?

[Voice of Reason]

Would you trade Stubbs and Chapman for Arod, Gardner, and Swisher?

 

I wouldn't give Chapman alone for those 3 plus Rivera and Jeter.

[newarkcatholicfan]

No.

 

I would never want my team to trade with the Yankees.

[stickymitts]

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

[formerkywrestler]

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd' date=' plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.[/quote']

 

This.

[HammerTime]

Edit...

 

Numbers were wrong.

[stickymitts]

This.

 

IF he goes anywhere, it will be to the Marlins, IMO.

[spindoc]

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

And remember, 87 dingers at GASP. He can hit in the 4 hole since Votto will never go yard again.

[stickymitts]

And remember, 87 dingers at GASP. He can hit in the 4 hole since Votto will never go yard again.

 

With a number like that I would definitely take him.

[CincySportsFan]

If he's a better option than who I have at 3rd, plus I can afford him without cutting elsewhere, yes. You would be stupid not to regardless of who it is.

 

Who you willing to give up in return?

[John Anthony]

88 mph fastball by him no thanks ill roll with Frazier for the term.

[ekubum]

For little money I'd want the Reds to take a gamble, and this is from a guy that hates A-Rod as a player. I still think he would look good between Votto and Bruce.

[NKY Bandit]

Would have loved to have him 10 years ago at half the price.