American Idol Top 12

[AverageJoesGym]

Cook is the winner!!!!! America got it right. The most talented person won. :dancingpa

 

I'm really glad he won. He's a much better performer and I think will be a star. Archuleta may very well be one as well, especially down the road but I think his poor stage presence did him in.

[panther15z30]

I think there were 9 others in the top 12 that were easily better than Arch. Cook was def. the best though.

[Birdsfan]

I think there were 9 others in the top 12 that were easily better than Arch. Cook was def. the best though.

No, I think Arch was definitely the best singer this year. But Cook had a little more maturity and a little better stage presence. That's what put him over the top.

[SvFan4life]

I think there were 9 others in the top 12 that were easily better than Arch. Cook was def. the best though.

 

Very laughable. Care to name who you think was better?

[greendevil]

No, I think Arch was definitely the best singer this year. But Cook had a little more maturity and a little better stage presence. That's what put him over the top.

 

:thumb:

 

Now, Castro on the other hand, after tonight, I thought he was the worst guy by far...

[SvFan4life]

Cook is the winner!!!!! America got it right. The most talented person won. :dancingpa

 

I thought we were watching American Idol not America's got Talent?

[4chs]

I'm no George Michael fan...............but he was really good on the song he sung last night on Idol.

 

I liked David Cook the best this year, with Michael Johns and the Irish lady next.