Tim Tebow/Florida

 

3,970 Yards

51 Total TD's

Darren McFadden/Arkansas

 

1,725 Yards rushing

20 TD

 

Colt Brennan/Hawaii

 

4,174 Yards Passing

46 TD

 

Chase Daniel/Missouri

I look for it to be close between:

 

Tebow and McFadden

 

With:

 

Tebow winning. But I would like to see McFadden win it.

McFadden gets my vote.

I think it will go to Tebow.

I think it will go to Tebow.

 

Yea me too.:eek:

Tebow is the poster boy for the Heisman, he will win it. In all honesty, he has changed the game. Every time a QB runs a lot, it is now called "Tebow". Many other college teams, some NFL teams, and some high school teams now substitute their QB's depending on what they want to do like they substitute RB, first down QB/RB and third down QB/RB. The game has been changed by Tebow, like him or not, he has done it.

 

I thought Chris Long was going to be a finalist. He received a letter saying he was high on the list. I thought it would be pretty nice to see a DL on the short list. He has allowed his team to win several games from the DL position, not many players can do that.

McFadden should get it. He played for a not so great team and done all he could, for the second year in a row.

That's who I thought would be there after White laid an egg. I think it's between Tebow and McFadden. I thought Tebow would win but for some reason I'm starting to feel McFadden. I can't lie, I'm torn! If I had to lay money I'd say Tebow but my gut says no McFadden. Help!

Tebow!!!!

Tebow.

I'd say Tebow will get it because of his ability to run and throw for TD's.

Tebow should get it. I thought 5 guys always got invited to New York?!

Tebow should get it. I thought 5 guys always got invited to New York?!

 

It was 3 last year wasn't it??

 

Smith, Quinn, and D.M. ?

McFadden should get it. He played for a not so great team and done all he could, for the second year in a row.

I agree. But it's hard to go against Tebow.

Dont count out Brennan, Hawaii Dosent get much attention but with those kind of numbers he definetly deserves to be there. Tebow will probably win only reason i see not is he is an Underclassman, You never know any more. Just dosen't seem as special as an award as it use to back in the day. Now it is about Numbers and Polotics. Doesnt always goes to the Best College Football player anymore. Just who has the best Numbers. And i dont think JUST good numbers mean you are the best player. It helps but not the only criteria JMO.

Im going with McFadden. If you take him from Arkansas they have a losing record. If you remove any of the other players their teams are still bowl eligible.