I believe it’s a fair question to ask with the three seasons he’s been there. Regardless of like, dislike, or other things, what do you think? Personally, I do like him but do question some. His track record is obviously there with beating ranked teams, particularly highly ranked teams. Unfortunately, he’s also got the track record of losing games that he shouldn’t. It just seems like the home front isn’t as strong as it’s been with other coaches from the past. 
 

What are thoughts on this from others, Louisville fans or not?

As it stands now, yes. 

His play calling has been abysmal. He needs to give up play calling duties. Brian Brohm (the OC) is useless. He’s not calling the plays and apparently he’s not developing any of the five QBs on the roster either.

He completely whiffed on Miller Moss and his stubbornness in not replacing him is costing him with the fans. The season is over. Put in one of the younger QBs and see if we have anything there. 

The “aura” around Brohm has always been about the big games he’s won. Yes, he’s won some big games throughout his career. Those games are irrelevant when you lose to bottom dwellers he traditionally loses to each year. Beating Top 10 Miami is irrelevant if you lose to 5-4 Cal.

19 minutes ago, TheDeuce said:

The “aura” around Brohm has always been about the big games he’s won. Yes, he’s won some big games throughout his career. Those games are irrelevant when you lose to bottom dwellers he traditionally loses to each year. Beating Top 10 Miami is irrelevant if you lose to 5-4 Cal.

It’s almost like home isn’t relevant any more against the teams that they should be beating to me too. With fairly good or better talent, this didn’t happen under Strong and as much as I hate saying his name, Petrino on his first go around. There’s been other good coaches too at longer ago times, but playing at home hasn’t been what it once was.

4 minutes ago, hrcarrier said:

It’s almost like home isn’t relevant any more against the teams that they should be beating to me too. With fairly good or better talent, this didn’t happen under Strong and as much as I hate saying his name, Petrino on his first go around. There’s been other good coaches too at longer ago times, but playing at home hasn’t been what it once was.

Petrino 1.0 a home game was a guaranteed win. Strong also held serve.

With this schedule, it’s absolutely inexcusable to have three home losses. 

Sounds like expectations may be just a little high in the Ville, who are you going to get for a replacement that could do better?

10 minutes ago, nikeman49 said:

Sounds like expectations may be just a little high in the Ville, who are you going to get for a replacement that could do better?

I don’t feel that way playing ACC football. Maybe I’m in the minority, but I don’t understand how you beat Miami on the road and lose to Virginia, California, and Clemson at home. Clemson and California are mediocre at best. The road win for Louisville against Virginia Tech was kind of a sign for what was coming though.

I will say know they will have a pretty good recruiting class coming in and all the transfers for next year.

I don't think so.  Not yet.   But changes will need to be made to move forward.  If they status quo, then yeah, this is what you get year in and year out.

5 minutes ago, Tranquility Base said:

I don't think so.  Not yet.   But changes will need to be made to move forward.  If they status quo, then yeah, this is what you get year in and year out.

This is kind of where I am. Change is definitely necessary, especially with the offense. 

Guys - I am lowly HS coach. But, I have come to the conclusion... (at least for now because I change my mind often) ... the best way to build a program is quality continuity. 

I have come to believe that some programs don't reach their potential or elite status because the leadership gets bored with the grind and the hard work/commitment required to be great. 

I can handle things are hard and we have a big mountain to climb. Nothing wrong with that. But, everyone must be committed to seeing it through and a willingness to do the tough, tedious work that is required. For some, it may even be boring at times. For me, I love the grind so am good to go. 

So...to answer the question..... I believe Louisville's best path to greatness is Coach Brohm working with their administration to build an elite program for an extended period of time. He is a good football coach and he cares about U of L Football. 

I think the same is true for Coach Stoop's and Kentucky.  

if the leadership & staff can walk through the door everyday with their hair on fire, and do so for an extended period of time, greatness can be achieved. 

Our culture likes quick fixes, splash hires and to be entertained. That can apply to administrators, fans, coaches, and players. None of the three are a replacement for consistent, quality hard work done by good, skilled people. 

 

13 minutes ago, ChiefSmoke said:

Guys - I am lowly HS coach. But, I have come to the conclusion... (at least for now because I change my mind often) ... the best way to build a program is quality continuity. 

I have come to believe that some programs don't reach their potential or elite status because the leadership gets bored with the grind and the hard work/commitment required to be great. 

I can handle things are hard and we have a big mountain to climb. Nothing wrong with that. But, everyone must be committed to seeing it through and a willingness to do the tough, tedious work that is required. For some, it may even be boring at times. For me, I love the grind so am good to go. 

So...to answer the question..... I believe Louisville's best path to greatness is Coach Brohm working with their administration to build an elite program for an extended period of time. He is a good football coach and he cares about U of L Football. 

I think the same is true for Coach Stoop's and Kentucky.  

if the leadership & staff can walk through the door everyday with their hair on fire, and do so for an extended period of time, greatness can be achieved. 

Our culture likes quick fixes, splash hires and to be entertained. That can apply to administrators, fans, coaches, and players. None of the three are a replacement for consistent, quality hard work done by good, skilled people. 

 

I agree that a lot want quicker fixes, unfortunately it’s just the time in too many ways. I think your point is spot on about coaches, administration, and more staying motivated and truly wanting to progress for longer hauls, which has unfortunately become fewer and further between. 

1 hour ago, nikeman49 said:

Sounds like expectations may be just a little high in the Ville, who are you going to get for a replacement that could do better?

It’s not necessarily about getting someone else, but there are some glaring inefficiencies that have been consistent over the last three years that have shown no signs of improving. 

22 hours ago, ChiefSmoke said:

Guys - I am lowly HS coach. But, I have come to the conclusion... (at least for now because I change my mind often) ... the best way to build a program is quality continuity. 

I have come to believe that some programs don't reach their potential or elite status because the leadership gets bored with the grind and the hard work/commitment required to be great. 

I can handle things are hard and we have a big mountain to climb. Nothing wrong with that. But, everyone must be committed to seeing it through and a willingness to do the tough, tedious work that is required. For some, it may even be boring at times. For me, I love the grind so am good to go. 

So...to answer the question..... I believe Louisville's best path to greatness is Coach Brohm working with their administration to build an elite program for an extended period of time. He is a good football coach and he cares about U of L Football. 

I think the same is true for Coach Stoop's and Kentucky.  

if the leadership & staff can walk through the door everyday with their hair on fire, and do so for an extended period of time, greatness can be achieved. 

Our culture likes quick fixes, splash hires and to be entertained. That can apply to administrators, fans, coaches, and players. None of the three are a replacement for consistent, quality hard work done by good, skilled people. 

 

Right on target Chief.

I've been a Louisville season ticket holder for years so have skin in the game. I think Brohm is a great coach and if have a better QB are probably undefeated. I think next year if has a better QB then will be better. Long term Brohm is the best option.