Is Vinatieri worthy of the Hall of Fame?

[Original Rookie]

What you guys think?

[Lucky Charms]

Yes, he's so clutch.

[Sportz Addict]

Absolutely.. he has had just as much to do with a team winning a SB.. as a RB/QB/WR.

[Fletch]

He could go in tomorrow if eligible.

[Hearsay]

Lock.

[cvillecat]

Yes, he is one of the best at what he does.

[The Breeze]

Definitely.

[romeo 4 president]

No doubt IMO...

[UKPat02]

Are there no kickers in the HOF right now?

[NEERFAN]

Start carving the bust.

[CatchMeIfYouCan]

YES!

 

21 yes

 

0 no

[RockPride]

^ I have never seen this sort of a unanimous decision on here.

[dolamite]

Most clutch kicker the game has ever seen, has to be.

 

In the snow, rain, it doesn't matter,......does he or will he ever miss an important post season kick???????

[HOMELESS CAMEL]

I believe they posted a stat tonight before his fifth field goal that he has only missed ONE post season field goal in his career. Just unbelievable.

 

Wouldn't it be a tad ironic that both Dungy and Manning's playoff misery ends after they get the kicker from the team that constantly beat them over the years.

 

Maybe even more ironic that "Vandajerk" is sitting at home now while his old team MAY be on their way to punching a ticket to Florida.

[RockPride]

^ I looked it up, I think that he has missed 5 post season fied goals....but that's still not many whatsoever.