November 29, 200619 yr Seriously, I'll give this a go. 1. Peyton Manning--he might come up small in the playoffs again but he's doing the job in the regular season. 2. Tom Brady--Nobody does more with less than this guy. 3. Drew Brees--coming off of surgery, onto a new team, he's one spot ahead of Rivers because he doesn't have LT or Gates. 4. Phillip Rivers--now we know why they let Brees go, they had someone just about as good holding a clipboard 5. Tony Romo--sure he's in his first year as a starter but look at the turnaround since he took over. How can you not have Palmer in your top 5? I mean just look at his numbers for this year, and he is easily one of the top 5 QB's in the league...
November 29, 200619 yr 1. Brady (has no one at receiver and still does good. He is unbelievable.) 2. Manning (Always is one of the best in the REGULAR SEASON.) 3. Palmer (Quietly getting close to having even better number this year than last year.) 4. Brees (Has done just an awesome job with the Saints this year.) 5. Rivers (Except for last week against Oakland, he has looked like a real veteran in this league.)
November 29, 200619 yr Lets wait on Romo until the year is over. 1. P. Manning 2. T. Brady 3. D. Brees 4. P. Rivers 5. C. Palmer
November 29, 200619 yr Lets wait on Romo until the year is over. 1. P. Manning 2. T. Brady 3. D. Brees 4. P. Rivers 5. C. Palmer Again the thread is about who is playing the best at this point in the season. That being said I would have Romo on my top 10 list but he would not crack my top five because he hasn't played as many games as the rest of the QB's. I understand that he is playing at a very high level right now, but he hasn't proven as much as the other QB's in the league.
November 30, 200619 yr Brees is on pace for 5k, that would be impressive. Manning Brees Palmer Rivers
November 30, 200619 yr Palmer Manning Brady Brees Rivers That is the top 5 in the league so far this year. The only thing to argue about is where you rank them within the 5. These 5 are a cut above the rest this season.
November 30, 200619 yr I know Bulger has had a couple of bad games lately, but he has got to be in there. Anyone who has Romo in there has to have Huard in there as well.
November 30, 200619 yr Author Lets wait on Romo until the year is over. 1. P. Manning 2. T. Brady 3. D. Brees 4. P. Rivers 5. C. Palmer ?....Why?... I said "UP TO THIS POINT".... Just for confirmation I mean the top QB's THIS SEASON so far THIS SEASON which I have already stated.
November 30, 200619 yr I know Bulger has had a couple of bad games lately, but he has got to be in there. Anyone who has Romo in there has to have Huard in there as well. And who would you put Bulger over? Manning, Palmer, Brees, River, Brady???
November 30, 200619 yr Bulger looks little better to me then these two. Remember we are not basing this on anything but this years preformance's. It's a different story of who would I want giuding my team on 2-minute drive. Brady Yds/ 2565 TD's/ 20 Int's/ 11 Rivers Yds/ 2440 TD's/ 15 Int's 6 Bulger Yds/ 2858 TD's/ 14 Int's/ 4
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.