Top 5 QB's In The NFL This Season....

[CatchMeIfYouCan]

up to this point which will be week 12 upcoming..right?

What's your opinion?

 

Here's Mine:

 

1) Peyton Manning - Indy

2) Tom Brady - Patriots

3) Carson Palmer - Bengals

4) Phillip Rivers - Chargers

5) Tony Romo - Cowboys

 

Next 5:

 

6) Drew Brees - Saints

7) Steve McNair - Ravens

8) Brett Favre - Packers

9) Matt Hasselbeck - Seahwaks

10) Chad Pennington - Jets

[KY Thorobred]

Donovan McNabb

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Drew Brees

Phillip Rivers/Tony Romo

[AverageJoesGym]

up to this point which will be week 12 upcoming..right?

What's your opinion?

 

Here's Mine:

 

1) Peyton Manning - Indy

2) Tom Brady - Patriots

3) Carson Palmer - Bengals

4) Phillip Rivers - Chargers

5) Tony Romo - Cowboys

 

Next 5:

 

6) Drew Brees - Chargers

7) Steve McNair - Ravens

8) Brett Favre - Packers

9) Matt Hasselbeck - Seahwaks

10) Chad Pennington - Jets

 

That's amazing that the Chargers could have 2 of the top 10 quarterbacks in the league this year......

[AverageJoesGym]

Seriously, I'll give this a go.

1. Peyton Manning--he might come up small in the playoffs again but he's doing the job in the regular season.

2. Tom Brady--Nobody does more with less than this guy.

3. Drew Brees--coming off of surgery, onto a new team, he's one spot ahead of Rivers because he doesn't have LT or Gates.

4. Phillip Rivers--now we know why they let Brees go, they had someone just about as good holding a clipboard

5. Tony Romo--sure he's in his first year as a starter but look at the turnaround since he took over.

[CatchMeIfYouCan]

Donovan McNabb

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Drew Brees

Phillip Rivers/Tony Romo

 

He is not even starting for the Eagles.....:confused:

[halfback20]

up to this point which will be week 12 upcoming..right?

What's your opinion?

 

Here's Mine:

 

1) Peyton Manning - Indy

2) Tom Brady - Patriots

3) Carson Palmer - Bengals

4) Phillip Rivers - Chargers

5) Tony Romo - Cowboys

 

Next 5:

 

6) Drew Brees - Saints

7) Steve McNair - Ravens

8) Brett Favre - Packers

9) Matt Hasselbeck - Seahwaks

10) Chad Pennington - Jets

 

 

I'd have Brees in the top 5, and Romo out of the top 5. He's going to have to do it for more than a few games before I consider him top 5. I'd take Favre and Brees, Hasslebeck and McNair over him for now.

[CatchMeIfYouCan]

Remember, this is for THIS SEASON & up to THIS POINT in this season...

[KY Thorobred]

He is not even starting for the Eagles.....:confused:

 

Probably not by choice, you do know that he tore his ACL right???

2647 through 10 games with 18 TD's and 6 INT's I don't see how you couldn't have him in your top 10. You said up to this point in the season, and I think that he has had the best year.

[CatchMeIfYouCan]

Probably not by choice, you do know that he tore his ACL right???

2647 through 10 games with 18 TD's and 6 INT's I don't see how you couldn't have him in your top 10. You said up to this point in the season, and I think that he has had the best year.

 

Yes, I do know he tore his ACL...

 

I did not include McNabb because he is DONE FOR THE YEAR

 

Can a mod put "Starting" QB in the thread title or something.......?

[KY Thorobred]

Yes, I do know he tore his ACL...

 

I did not include McNabb because he is DONE FOR THE YEAR

 

Can a mod put "Starting" QB in the thread title or something.......?

 

Then maybe you should ask who the best QB for week 13 is because McNabb obviously has the stats to be in the top 5 this year atleast up to his injury.

[MJAlltheWay24]

I think that Dree Brees has to be in the top five.

[jahearme]

1. D. Brees

2. T. Brady

3. P. Manning

4. M. Bulger

5a. T. Romo

5b. C. Palmer

[halfback20]

I think that Dree Brees has to be in the top five.

 

 

:thumb: He leads the league in passing, and has led the SAINTS to a 7-4 record.

 

1.Peyton Manning

2.Tom Brady

3.Drew Brees

4.Carson Palmer

5.Phillip Rivers or Favre or McNair or Hasslebeck

[HHSDad]

Yes, I do know he tore his ACL...

 

I did not include McNabb because he is DONE FOR THE YEAR

 

Can a mod put "Starting" QB in the thread title or something.......?

Based on your first post, I'd definitely put McNabb in the top 5.

[NobizLikeShowbiz]

1.Manning

2.Brady

3.Rivers

4.Palmer

5.Brees