November 30, 200619 yr Bulger looks little better to me then these two. Remember we are not basing this on anything but this years preformance's. It's a different story of who would I want giuding my team on 2-minute drive. Brady Yds/ 2565 TD's/ 20 Int's/ 11 Rivers Yds/ 2440 TD's/ 15 Int's 6 Bulger Yds/ 2858 TD's/ 14 Int's/ 4 Bulgers numbers are very impressive, but I still would take Brady and Rivers over him in my top 5. Because Brady has alot less to work with and he is still putting up good numbers and getting wins, and that makes him a top 5 QB this year still IMO. And well actually I dont know if I would take Rivers over Brees or vice versa. It is hard to choose between the two now after seeing Bulgers actual stats. I would have them at 5A and 5B
November 30, 200619 yr If we're going on this season alone: 1) Phillip Rivers 2) Peyton Manning 3) Tom Brady 4) Drew Brees 5) Carson Palmer 6) Donavon McNabb 7) Tony Romo 8) Marc Bulger 9) Brett Favre 10) David Carr 11) Steve McNair 12) Alex Smith 13) David Garrard 14) Eli Manning 15) Jake Delhomme 16) Bruce Gradkowski 17) Damon Huard 18) Matt Hasselbeck 19) Jake Plummer 20) Rex Grossman 21) Joey Harrington 22) Brad Johnson 23) Charlie Frye 24) Vince Young 25) Chad Pennington 26) Michael Vick 27) Matt Leinhart 28) John Kitna 29) Ben Rothlisberger 30) Jason Campbell 31) J.P. Losman 32) Andrew Walters
November 30, 200619 yr I simply don't understand Brady being 1 or 2... he was extremely average in the first half of their season and also threw 4 picks against Indy. P.Manning D.Brees C.Palmer P.Rivers T.Brady
November 30, 200619 yr If we're going on this season alone: 1) Phillip Rivers 2) Peyton Manning 3) Tom Brady 4) Drew Brees 5) Carson Palmer 6) Donavon McNabb 7) Tony Romo 8) Marc Bulger 9) Brett Favre 10) David Carr 11) Steve McNair 12) Alex Smith 13) David Garrard 14) Eli Manning 15) Jake Delhomme 16) Bruce Gradkowski 17) Damon Huard 18) Matt Hasselbeck 19) Jake Plummer 20) Rex Grossman 21) Joey Harrington 22) Brad Johnson 23) Charlie Frye 24) Vince Young 25) Chad Pennington 26) Michael Vick 27) Matt Leinhart 28) John Kitna 29) Ben Rothlisberger 30) Jason Campbell 31) J.P. Losman 32) Andrew Walters I am no Vick fan but 26? No way.
November 30, 200619 yr I am no Vick fan but 26? No way. It may not be his fault, but he's looked awful the past 3-4 weeks. If he can consistantly play the way he did against the Bengals then he's top 5 IMO, but right now he's one of the worst.
November 30, 200619 yr ?....Why?... I said "UP TO THIS POINT".... Just for confirmation I mean the top QB's THIS SEASON so far THIS SEASON which I have already stated. Yeah and up to this point he's played in what..FOUR GAMES? Get off of Romo for a few seconds, take a step back and look at the big picture. He hasn't played enough to prove he's anything yet. Let him do it for a full season or even more than 3 or so games, then talk him up. He's not top five FOR THIS SEASON or any other season yet.
November 30, 200619 yr It may not be his fault, but he's looked awful the past 3-4 weeks. If he can consistantly play the way he did against the Bengals then he's top 5 IMO, but right now he's one of the worst. At least Vick as shown some signs of being a very good QB this year. Some of the guys listed ahead of him haven't at all really.
November 30, 200619 yr Author Yeah and up to this point he's played in what..FOUR GAMES? Get off of Romo for a few seconds, take a step back and look at the big picture. He hasn't played enough to prove he's anything yet. Let him do it for a full season or even more than 3 or so games, then talk him up. He's not top five FOR THIS SEASON or any other season yet. He has only started five games, but he looks like a 10-year veteran. He shredded a proud Bucs defense on Thanksgiving. He threw a team-record five TD passes and he continues to manage the game well. He is playing almost mistake-free football and he has energized the Cowboys franchise....
November 30, 200619 yr Author I am no Vick fan but 26? No way. I agree, Vick should be higher (not to much higher) but I mean he might be even higher as a running back instead as a QB who runs 90% of the time. I rate him #2 in running backs behind LT By the way, I know Vick is a much better "QB" than he has been in the past
November 30, 200619 yr He has only started five games, but he looks like a 10-year veteran. He shredded a proud Bucs defense on Thanksgiving. He threw a team-record five TD passes and he continues to manage the game well. He is playing almost mistake-free football and he has energized the Cowboys franchise.... A proud Bucs defense that ranks 23rd in the league in total defense, 22nd against the pass. He's playing well, but he's only played in a few games...I think the jury is still out on him.
November 30, 200619 yr A proud Bucs defense that ranks 23rd in the league in total defense, 22nd against the pass. :laugh:
November 30, 200619 yr Author A proud Bucs defense that ranks 23rd in the league in total defense, 22nd against the pass. He's playing well, but he's only played in a few games...I think the jury is still out on him. Has any other QB through for 5 TD passes vs the Bucs' ? No matter what Tampa Bay ranks in the league on D Romo still through for a Cowboys record 5 TD passes..(A couple of other "decent" QB's have played for the boys in the past & did not throw 5 TD's in one game)
November 30, 200619 yr Author Yeah and up to this point he's played in what..FOUR GAMES? Get off of Romo for a few seconds, take a step back and look at the big picture. He hasn't played enough to prove he's anything yet. Let him do it for a full season or even more than 3 or so games, then talk him up. He's not top five FOR THIS SEASON or any other season yet. Romo has the highest QB rating in the NFL so far this season...110.8 The only other payer with a 100+ QB rating is Peyton....100.2
November 30, 200619 yr Romo has the highest QB rating in the NFL so far this season...110.8 The only other payer with a 100+ QB rating is Peyton....100.2 He's Played In 3 :scared: Games!!!!!!
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.