Watson or Winston?

[NKYknowitall]

Winston- 26-1 (2 years) 7964 yards passing, 65 TD's, 28 INT's, 284 yds rushing 7 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- BCS National Championship

- consensus All American

- ACC Player of the Year

- ACC Male Athlete of the Year

 

Watson- 32-3 (3 years) 8997 yards passing, 76 TD's, 30 INT's, 1734 yds rushing 21 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- CFP National Championship

- 1st Team All American

- 2nd Team All American

- ACC Player of the Year

 

Both won 2 ACC titles as well.

[GrantNKY]

Winston because I like what he does pre-snap and he reads defenses much better than Watson. Both have the gunslinger mentality where they feel they can make any throw to any part of the field. Even though Watson has superior physical skills IMO, I'll still take Winston.

[Clyde]

For what?

 

NFL?

College?

[NKYknowitall]

For what?

 

NFL?

College?

 

Well considering Watson isn't in the NFL yet, it's comparing their bodies of work in College, so college

[Clyde]

Well considering Watson isn't in the NFL yet, it's comparing their bodies of work in College, so college

 

Bodies of work. Gotcha.

 

Both crazy good careers.

 

Heisman for Jameison would be the reason I'd go with him if forced to pick.

[woodsrider]

Winston- 26-1 (2 years) 7964 yards passing, 65 TD's, 28 INT's, 284 yds rushing 7 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- BCS National Championship

- consensus All American

- ACC Player of the Year

- ACC Male Athlete of the Year

 

Watson- 32-3 (3 years) 8997 yards passing, 76 TD's, 30 INT's, 1734 yds rushing 21 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- CFP National Championship

- 1st Team All American

- 2nd Team All American

- ACC Player of the Year

 

Both won 2 ACC titles as well.

Watson didn't win the Heisman

[Hatz]

Winston- 26-1 (2 years) 7964 yards passing, 65 TD's, 28 INT's, 284 yds rushing 7 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- BCS National Championship

- consensus All American

- ACC Player of the Year

- ACC Male Athlete of the Year

 

Watson- 32-3 (3 years) 8997 yards passing, 76 TD's, 30 INT's, 1734 yds rushing 21 TD's

- Heisman Winner

- CFP National Championship

- 1st Team All American

- 2nd Team All American

- ACC Player of the Year

 

Both won 2 ACC titles as well.

 

Watson didn't win the Heisman.

[UK#1fanisback]

Winston he is a unreal leader.

[NKYknowitall]

Watson didn't win the Heisman

 

Correct... my mistake, haha

[jericho]

Watson should have won it this year.

[Tall Trees]

Watson

[GrizzlyAdams]

Winston as a prospect blows Watson away. Winstons only drawback was his off the field issues. I like Watson alot and think he should be the first QB off the board, but he isnt as good as a prospect that Winston was.

 

 

Edit: I compared them as prospects for the NFL....

[Samcro]

Winston

[futurecoach]

In College I would have taken Watson. As Pro QB's I would rather have Winston.

[Cats3x]

Cam Newton .

 

I'll take Watson as a college QB. But both are fantastic.