Active Hall of Fame QB's?

[UKMustangFan]

Thought this could be an interesting thread. Which active QBs does BGP think are Hall of Famers when it's all said and done?

 

Vote for as many as you feel will be in Canton.

[MentschTrachtGottLacht]

......

 

Definite:

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Aaron Rodgers

Drew Brees

 

Probably:

Big Ben

Eli Manning

 

Maybe, much left to do:

Luck

Flacco

Romo

Ryan

[2 Humped Camel]

For sure: Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Big Ben, Drew Brees

Really close already: Aaron Rodgers and Eli Manning

Probably will get there based on talent: Andrew Luck

I think the only other guy on the list that may have a chance is Matt Ryan. Most of the others listed are good enough or are a dual threat QB that will be to often injured.

[UKMustangFan]

For sure: Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Big Ben, Drew Brees

Really close already: Aaron Rodgers and Eli Manning

Probably will get there based on talent: Andrew Luck

I think the only other guy on the list that may have a chance is Matt Ryan. Most of the others listed are good enough or are a dual threat QB that will be to often injured.

 

I tend to agree, although I think you could throw Wilson, Kaepernick, and Romo into that possibly category. If Romo wins a ring ever (stop laughing, I'm being serious), I think he's a shoe in with his statistical numbers.

[2 Humped Camel]

I tend to agree, although I think you could throw Wilson, Kaepernick, and Romo into that possibly category. If Romo wins a ring ever (stop laughing, I'm being serious), I think he's a shoe in with his statistical numbers.

 

I agree about Romo and that is a huge if.

[MJAlltheWay24]

I voted P Manning, Brees, Brady, Rodgers, and Luck.

[DragonFire]

I voted for most of the same as everyone else, but added on Romo and Newton. Romo's a bit of a leap, but Cam I think has the tools to do it. Obviously he's got a long way to go.

[UKMustangFan]

Is this the "Golden Age of QBs"? Seems like an awful lot of HoF'ers are currently playing.

[Clyde]

......

 

Definite:

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Aaron Rodgers

Drew Brees

 

Probably:

Big Ben

Eli Manning

 

Maybe, much left to do:

Luck

Flacco

Romo

Ryan

 

Agree on definites.

 

I add Big Ben to the definite list.

 

Eli is a probably but I didn't vote for him. 2 rings probably gets him in.

 

I think Luck will get there.

 

Didn't vote for any others.

[JCVD]

Dalton

[2 Humped Camel]

Is this the "Golden Age of QBs"? Seems like an awful lot of HoF'ers are currently playing.

 

It's the Golden age of rules set up to help QB's and WR's. I think the football world will have to adjust what is considered to be HOF numbers accordingly.

[Clyde]

I voted for most of the same as everyone else, but added on Romo and Newton. Romo's a bit of a leap, but Cam I think has the tools to do it. Obviously he's got a long way to go.

 

 

Cam ? No way I can even make a stretch to see him in the HOF.

[rjs4470]

I'm not so sure about Big Ben or Eli. The two rings certainly help and put them in a rare category. But statistically, they haven't put up huge numbers in an era when huge numbers are pretty common. Also no MVP's for either and I don't think either ever had even a year (let alone several) where they were considered one of the top 3 or 4 QB's. I think they both need one more ring and a few big years to be sure things.

 

I think the only sure bets right now are Peyton, Brees, and Brady. Rodgers is close, but needs a few more big years and/or another ring.

[Hellbird]

Definite:

Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees.

 

Probable:

Aaron Rodgers

 

Maybe:

Big Ben

 

Media overrates so they may get a shot: Eli Manning

[Hellbird]

I tend to agree, although I think you could throw Wilson, Kaepernick, and Romo into that possibly category. If Romo wins a ring ever (stop laughing, I'm being serious), I think he's a shoe in with his statistical numbers.

 

There is no way you can add first year NFL QB's to the list. That is insane. It's not a popularity contest, although much of the voting is.

 

Lamper nick, Wilson and Luck should not be in the conversation after only 1 year.